Content from this article is duplicated in Chapter 19 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE PROPHET.

 

In this article, we will examine instances of the promotion of New Age beliefs and practices by four prominent Christian leaders in evangelicalism.

 

Robert Schuller

Televangelist Robert Schuller’s weekly television program Hour of Power was broadcast for over five decades from the famous Crystal Cathedral in Garden Grove, California. In the 1980s, A Course in Miracles was sold in the Crystal Cathedral’s bookstore, Schuller had a copy in his own office, and small groups based on the book met at the Crystal Cathedral.1 As a reminder, the book teaches that humanity is one with God, there is no sin, and no need for an atonement or a savior.

 

Psychiatrist and New Age author Dr. Gerald Jampolsky traveled the world teaching his 12 principles of “Attitudinal Healing,” based on A Course in Miracles.2 Robert Schuller deceptively implied Dr. Jampolsky was a Christian and highly endorsed his work in two of his books (19823, 19854) and in two Hour of Power episodes (20035, 20046).

 

Schuller advocated meditation (1978)7 and taught the New Age doctrine of God’s immanence in every person (2003).8 He also challenged Christian leaders to rise above divisive doctrinal differences with other major religions and exercise religious inclusivity (2001)9, for which he was publicly praised by New Age luminary Neale Donald Walsch (2002).10

 

Schuller profoundly influenced Saddleback Church founder and prolific Christian author Rick Warren.11 Like Schuller, Warren at times endorsed New Age leaders, such as celebrity Dr. Bernie Siegel (2002),12 who spent decades following a spirit guide he said he met during a 1978 meditation seminar.13

 

William Paul Young and The Shack

William Paul Young’s 2007 novel The Shack has sold over 20 million copies14 and was made into a Hollywood film.15 Young credited iconic New Age pioneer Kahlil Gibran for providing creative stimulation behind the book.16 An outspoken universalist, Young affirmed the New Age doctrine that God/Christ is within every single person and said it is a lie that people need to be saved.17 Young endorsed a 2012 theological analysis of The Shack published by theologian C. Baxter Kruger,18 who likewise affirmed the New Age doctrine of God’s immanence in every human being.19,20

 

The Message by Eugene Peterson

The Message paraphrase of the Bible was first authored by Eugene Peterson in 1993. It employs New Age and occult language in key scriptures. In The Lord’s Prayer in Matthew 6:9-10, it replaces “on earth as it is in heaven” with “as above, so below.” New Age forerunners such as Helena Blavatsky21 and Alice Baily22 affirmed that “as above, so below” refers to mankind’s New Age destiny to awaken to his divine nature with help from the ascended masters.23 Eugene Peterson claimed in the 1990s that he would never have included this phrase if he knew its occult/New Age origin, yet he did not remove it from the 2002 and 2018 revisions of The Message.24

 

In word-for-word Bible translations (e.g. NASB, NKJV, YLT), there are between 4 and 8 verses in which Jesus is addressed as “Master.” The full title of “Master Jesus” is never used. However, in the Message paraphrase, Jesus is called “Master” about 150 times and is identified with the full title “Master Jesus” 73 times. Master Jesus is the title of the New Age ascended master named Jesus, who works to awaken mankind to his divinity alongside the other ascended masters such as Djwhal Khul, who dictated Alice Bailey’s works.

 

In the opening illustration of Jesus’s most famous sermon (the Sermon on the Mount), Jesus pointed out in Matthew 5:15 that no one who lights a lamp puts it under a basket, but rather puts it on a lampstand. However, in The Message paraphrase, Jesus said he wants to turn his followers into “light-bearers.” The first hits of an internet search with virtually any search engine reveal that “light-bearer” is synonymous with the name Lucifer. New Age forerunners such as Helena Blavatsky and Alice Baily likewise used the term “light-bearer” in reference to Lucifer.25,26,27

 

Sarah Young’s Jesus Calling

Sarah Young’s 2004 book Jesus Calling has sold over 40 million copies and spawned a 10-million-download podcast, three television series, and many other lucrative products.28 The book features Jesus Christ speaking in the first person. It is based on personalized messages Young purportedly began receiving from Jesus after being inspired by the 1978 best-seller God Calling, which is written similarly.29

 

Evangelical luminary John Ankerberg called God Calling a channeled text that is replete with denials of biblical teachings, such as when Jesus appeared to claim God indwells every single person, God needs us more than we need Him, and human beings can give God commands. Ankerberg said channeling involves using meditation or visualization to permit a spirit entity to give teachings or practical advice through inner voice dictation, visions, or automatic writing. He added the spirit entities deceitfully claim to be wise and loving to establish trust.30

 

In the original version of Jesus Calling, Young said her daily messages from God became the most important and formative discipline in her life. She also said the book was meant to help others begin having their own similar experiences.31 Even though Young knew Christians could receive unbiblical, distorted, or deceiving messages using her method, none of her books included any warnings about this danger.32   

 

Many evangelicals considered the book misleading and dangerous.33 When Thomas Nelson released the 10th Anniversary edition of the book, it eliminated every reference to the book God Calling. It eliminated every variation of the words “receive” or “message.” It eliminated Young’s statements about yearning for her daily messages more than the Bible. And it eliminated an invitation for readers to begin journaling their own impressions from God.34 Thomas Nelson vaguely explained that the changes made the book easier to understand and cleared up some confusion.35

 

Young repeatedly cited Psalm 46:10 to support her use of meditation and visualization to receive messages from God.36 However, a plain reading of the passage in context indicates Psalm 46:10 is not a call to meditation. A useful website for examining reputable biblical commentaries for a given passage of scripture is https://biblehub.com/. The commentaries quoted for Psalm 46:10 include:

 

1)      Benson Commentary

2)      Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges

3)      Pulpit Commentary

4)      Barnes’ Notes on the Bible

5)      Matthew Henry’s Concise Commentary

6)      Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary

7)      Matthew Poole’s Commentary

8)      Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

9)      Geneva Study Bible

 

Every single one agrees that Psalm 46:10 is a call to God’s people to trust in His protective intervention and/or a call to God’s enemies to cease their defiance. Not one suggests it is a call to meditation or contemplative prayer. Further, biblical meditation involves setting one’s mind on God’s word, law, works, or testimonies (e.g. Psalm 1:2, 143:5, 199:99, 148).

 

Interestingly, Psalm 46:10 is deceptively invoked by the New Age movement as an encouragement to establish contact with spirit entities. Examples include New Age leader Edgar Cayce, the world-famous New Age community of Findhorn in Scotland, and the book A Course in Miracles.37 Young’s “Jesus” also employed many common New Age terms, including exhorting every follower to become a light-bearer.38

 

 

1.       Warren Smith, 2004, Deceived on Purpose: The New Age Implications of the Purpose-Driven Church, pgs. 88-89, 92-94, Chapter 7

2.       Gerald Jampolsky, 1970, Love is Letting Go of Fear, Dedication, Acknowledgements

3.       Robert Schuller, 1982, Self-Esteem: The New Reformation, pg. 123

4.       Robert Schuller, 1985, The Be (Happy) Attitudes: Eight Positive Attitudes that Can Transform Your Life, pg. 150

5.       Hour of Power, 2003, “Become a Peacemaker,” by Robert Schuller

6.       Hour of Power, 10/10/2004, “Jerry Jampolsky, MD & Diane Cirincione, Ph.D.,” Interview by Robert Schuller

7.       Robert Schuller, 1978, Discover Your Possibilities, pgs. 3, 128-129

8.       Hour of Power, 11/9/2003, Program #1762: “God’s Word: Rebuild, Renew, Restore, Robert Schuller

9.       Robert Schuller, 2001, My Journey: From an Iowa Farm to a Cathedral of Dreams, pgs. 801, 818

10.   Neale Donald Walsch, 2002, The New Revelations: A Conversation with God, pgs. 281-282

11.   Christianity Today, 11/18/2002, “A Regular Purpose-Driven Guy”

12.   Time, 3/10/2009, “Rick Warren’s Magazine: A Publishing Leap of Faith”

13.   Bernie Siegel, 1986, Love, Medicine & Miracles, pgs. 18-20

14.   Washington Post, 3/3/2017, “‘The Shack’ once sold millions of books. But the film doesn’t fit the Trump era.”

15.   Christianity Today, 10/16/2017, “Was The Shack movie a success?”

16.   William Paul Young, 2007, The Shack, Acknowledgements

17.   William Paul Young, 2017, Lies We Believe About God, Chapter 13, pgs. 118-119

18.   C. Baxter Kruger, 2012, The Shack Revisited: There Is More Going On Here than You Ever Dared to Dream, introduction

19.   Ibid., pg. 49

20.   C. Baxter Kruger, 2016, Three Days, Two Men, One Extraordinary Conversation, pg. 93

21.   Helena Blavatsky, 1887, Isis Unveiled: A Master-Key to the Mysteries of Ancient and Modern Science and Theology, Volume 1, pgs. 35, 306

22.   Alice Baily, 1957, Externalization of the Hierarchy, pg. 350

23.   The Editors of the New Age Journal, 1992, New Age Journal, As Above, So Below: Paths to Spiritual Renewal in Daily Life, pg. xi

24.   Warren Smith, 2023, Evangullible, pgs. 90-91

25.   Helena Blavatsky, 1888, The Secret Doctrine, Volume 2, pg. 513

26.   Lucis Trust Website, “The Esoteric Meaning of Lucifer”

27.   The Beacon, September-October 1989, “Descent and Sacrifice

28.   Publisher’s Weekly, 5/25/2022, “As ‘Jesus Calling’ Sells 40M Copies, Brand Expands”

29.   Sarah Young, 2004, Jesus Calling: Enjoying Peace in His Presence, Introduction

30.   John Ankerberg, John Welton, 1996, The Encyclopedia of New Age Beliefs, pgs. 79-80, 103

31.   Young, 2004, Introduction

32.   Christian Broadcasting Network, 7/7/2016, “Q & A With Sarah Young”

33.   The Daily Beast, 2/23/2014, “The Strange Saga of ‘Jesus Calling,’ the Evangelical Bestseller You’ve Never Heard Of”

34.   Sarah Young, 2014, Jesus Calling: Enjoying Peace in His Presence, 10th Anniversary Edition

35.   The Daily Beast, 2/23/2014

36.   Young, 2004, Introduction, pg. 258

37.   Warren Smith, 2018, “Jesus Calling, Contemplative Prayer, the New Age, and Psalm 46:10”

38.   Young, 2004, Introduction, pg. 214