Randal Rauser is an author and
Theology Professor at Taylor Seminary in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. In his 2021
book, Jesus Loves Canaanites, Rauser makes his case for interpreting
scripture using what he calls the “providential errancy view.” According
to this view, God sovereignly chose the content of scripture, but this does not
mean a given passage is historically accurate or correct. Rauser explains (pg.
162):
“For
every passage there is both the primary author and the second human author,
their voices may differ, and if they conflict then the divine author takes
priority over the human author. Further, many errors of the human author were
inerrantly included by the divine author/editor… The guide for interpreting
this text is the life and teachings of Jesus.”
The implications of this view are
truly massive and are perhaps best understood by surveying some of the articles
on Rauser’s website. For example, he asserts that many of the people and events
in the Old Testament were not necessarily literal or historical, such as Adam
and Eve, Noah and the flood, and Lot and Sodom and Gomorrah.
Of course, Jesus, Paul, Peter, and the
writer of Hebrews reference all of these individuals/events without ever
stating or even hinting that they didn’t exist or that the passages that depict
them should be taken non-literally. Nevertheless, Rauser contends that Jesus
and the New Testament writers could have been referencing them merely as “well
recognized literary figures.”
Using this view, Rauser further
asserts that there is no need for genuine Christians to subscribe to
traditional doctrines such as eternal judgment or the substitutionary atonement
view of the cross. He also questions the necessity of obeying certain direct
moral commands, such as abstaining from homosexual acts.
For Rauser, it is often unimportant
and unknowable whether a particular Bible story is true. What is important is
that we use our “human moral intuition” to discern the overarching
lesson of the text that aligns with Jesus’ core teaching of loving God and
loving others. This also applies to deciding which moral commandments should be
taken at face value and how they should be applied.
An obvious objection to this teaching
is that human ideas about how to love God and others often vary from one person
to the next and are subject to ongoing perversion by the deceitfulness of the
human heart and demonic spiritual influences. This perversion can even progress
to the point of calling evil good and good evil, as it says in Isaiah 5:20.
RANDAL RAUSER’S CASE FOR REJECTING THE
HISTORICAL JOSHUA NARRATIVE
If Jesus and the New Testament writers
did not state or even hint that Old Testament individuals/events were not
historical, what is the basis for Rauser’s view? In his book, it is centered on
Israel’s destruction of the people groups inhabiting the promise land in Joshua
1-12, which God commanded in Deuteronomy 7, 12, 20. Rauser asserts that these
passages depict an evil deity ordering a genocidal atrocity on par with
Hitler’s extermination of the Jews. Therefore, since these passages are totally
irreconcilable with a loving God as portrayed by the life and teachings of
Jesus, the only option is to treat them as non-literal.
Not only does Rauser fail to make a
strong case for this argument, he presents it with breathtaking duplicity, as
we will see shortly.
In
Deuteronomy 12:29-31, 18:9-10, God specifies that their acts of worship include
sacrificing their own children to be burned alive in worship to the god Molech.
Many additional passages record not only that the promise land inhabitants
engaged in child sacrifice to Molech, but also that Israel eventually adopted
this practice and incurred God’s judgment, just as He warned. Such passages
include: 2 Kings 16:3, 17:15-17, 23:10, 2 Chronicles
28:3, 33:6, Psalm 106:34-38, Jeremiah 7:31, 19:5, 32:35, Ezekiel 16:20-21,
20:26, 31, 23:37.
I bought this book for the sole
purpose of finding out how Rauser would deal with this issue. I found his
response to it both pitiful and shocking. On page 174, he claims that the
people groups inhabiting the promise land were not uniquely sinful at all, and
that saying they were is a “deeply misguided attempt to demonize an ancient
people as worthy of destruction due to sin.” To justify this claim, Rauser
cites Wheaton professor John Walton (The Lost World of the Israelite
Conquest, 2017) as teaching that “the Joshua narrative… conforms to a
familiar ancient literary trope.”
This justification fails miserably. So
what if Joshua resembles an ancient literary trope? The point remains that God
plainly stated that the promise land inhabitants were uniquely sinful –
including child sacrifice as worship – and must be wiped out lest their evil
ways infect the Israelites. By claiming this is not the case, Rauser
preemptively treats Deuteronomy 7:2-4, 12:29-31, 18:9-10, 20:17-18, 2 Kings
16:3, 17:15-17, 2 Chronicles 28:3, 33:6, Psalm 106:34-38, Jeremiah 7:31, 19:6,
32:35, Ezekiel 16:20-21, 20:26, 31, 23:37 as non-literal/erroneous.
In other words, Rauser claims the
Joshua narrative cannot be literal because it is atrocious, yet he “proves” it
is atrocious by not taking scripture literally. This is circular reasoning.
Thus, Rauser offers no proof whatsoever for his central premise.
If Rauser simply took Deuteronomy
7:2-4, 12:29-31, 18:9-10, 20:17-18, 2 Kings 16:3, 17:15-17, 2 Chronicles 28:3,
33:6, Psalm 106:34-38, Jeremiah 7:31, 19:6, 32:35, Ezekiel 16:20-21, 20:26, 31,
23:37 at face value, then the Joshua narrative is no longer atrocious and there
is no reason to treat it as non-literal.
Rauser is supposedly a Bible teacher.
Therefore, as a starting point, he should at least clearly articulate what the
Bible says or doesn’t say. Rauser did not acknowledge even once that the Bible
says the promise land inhabitants practiced child sacrifice. He never mentioned
Deuteronomy 18:9-10, 2 Kings 16:3, 17:15-17, 2 Chronicles 28:3, 33:6, Psalm
106:34-38, Jeremiah 7:31, 19:6, 32:35, Ezekiel 16:20-21, 20:26, 31, 23:37, and
he only mentioned Deuteronomy 12:29-31 in Chapter 4 as part of a hypothetical
conversation illustrating the importance of human moral reasoning, never adding
that it was talking about the promise land inhabitants. Instead, he framed
child-sacrifice by the promise land inhabitants as the unsupported assertion of
politicized right-wingers. This tactic was extremely dishonest and deceptive.
As a side note, Rauser attempts to
analyze the psychological trauma that might have been sustained by Israelite
men who carried out God’s orders to destroy the promise land inhabitants. While
reading this portion, I found myself asking:
“How
about analyzing the psychology of a civilization where placing children into a
massive furnace is not only a legal act, not only a culturally and socially
acceptable act, but is actually considered an act of worship to the god your
society venerates?”
Rauser’s anti-biblical claim that the
promise land inhabitants were not uniquely sinful is a foundational requirement
for his larger narrative that they were really innocent victims of genocide,
not unlike the Jews during Hitler’s holocaust. Rauser deliberately uses the
term genocide throughout the book (including the subtitle), in contrast
to mass killing. In other words, he asserts with zero scriptural support
that God’s commands in Deut. 7, 12, 20 are actually rooted in hatred for their
ethnicities, instead of their sinful worship and its potential for corrupting
the Israelites, as the passages plainly state. Rauser even insists that the
Israelites engaged in mockery, torture, mutilation, and rape of the promise
land inhabitants (pgs. 117-119) since historical genocides have always included
these elements.
In summary, Rauser ignores and
reverses the plain teaching of scripture to depict the promise land inhabitants
as innocent victims and God as an evil, racist monster. He then uses his
fabricated “evidence” to “debunk” a literal interpretation of scripture and
espouse the “providential errancy view.” Using this view, he questions
the existence of key individuals and events recorded in scripture, downplays
the importance of doctrinal clarity, and even opens the door to ignoring direct
moral commands.
A FINAL THOUGHT
The “providential errancy view”
strikes me as a sort of loophole whereby professing Christians can claim to
believe in the inerrancy of scripture while still rejecting anything they don’t
like. When I sit down to read my Bible, it kicks God out of the driver’s seat,
and empowers me to interpret it however I wish.