Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 17 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
In a
four-part message on contemplative prayer at IHOP on July 19 through July 22,
2001, 1,2,3,4 Mike Bickle described his own prayer life as heavily
incorporating elements of mantra meditation and silent meditation, by which he
received spiritual impressions. He stated:
“I set my mind. I focus… internally… on the
internal communing… I was taught by the contemplative books some years ago that
you don’t want a lot of words…”
“I start with the phrases, ‘Consuming Fire,
seal me with love.’ …I speak the phrase, then pause for a moment or two. After
a few minutes, I throw away all the phrases and I just say, ‘Consuming.’ …It
isn’t rushed.”
“It becomes wordless in a really short amount
of time. There are no words… When my mind gets distracted… I say the words…
[and] it makes my mind obedient… but
there’s a lock-in point when I don’t say the words. Then a minute, two, three,
four, five, ten minutes goes by.”
“Then… little impressions come up here and
there… manifestations touch me, those divine hints. Then I say what comes to
me.”
As with
his teachings on manifestations, Bickle gave no warnings about the dangers of
demonic counterfeits. Instead, he rationalized this approach by claiming that
transcendental (mantra) meditation is a counterfeit of biblical, contemplative
prayer. And he falsely assured his youthful audience that the practice is
perfectly safe if is it done out of love for Jesus. Bickle stated:
“…Transcendental Meditation… is the
counterfeit of contemplative prayer… [because it has] nothing to do with the
Bible or the Spirit… Our safety is in our focus on the Man Christ Jesus and a
radical commitment to the Scriptures and a radical commitment to love. That’s
our safety… You don’t even go outside of the boundaries of Jesus in the written
Word of God…”
Bickle’s
claim is false that the practice he described is safe and keeping within the
boundaries of scripture. If we are applying Eastern/New Age techniques to
conjure spiritual experiences on our own initiative, in violation of scripture,
and then asking the Holy Spirit to protect and bless us, we should absolutely
fear receiving a counterfeit. Further, Biblical meditation is merely setting
one’s mind on God’s word, law, works, or testimonies (e.g. Psalm 1:2, 143:5, 199:99,
148). By contrast, New Age meditation seeks a spiritual experience by achieving
altered states of consciousness using techniques such as sensory deprivation,
stillness of mind, inward concentration, mantra repetition, and/or mental
visualization. Bickle clearly endorsed the latter.
Within
Christendom, the terms typically used for meditation/mindfulness-type practices
are contemplative prayer or centering prayer. Bickle further
asserted that contemplative prayer is something that all Christians should
practice regularly. He stated:
“Everyone in the body of Christ is called to
the contemplative lifestyle.”
“The Holy Spirit is restoring contemplative
prayer to the body of Christ.”
Further
still, Bickle told IHOP students that he wanted them to go deep into
contemplative prayer for decades to come. He modeled that they should buy every
book on the topic they could find regardless of whether it was doctrinally
accurate. He even implied that it would be arrogant to not read a book just
because it is doctrinally inaccurate. Finally, Bickle warned the students they would
never grow spiritually if they exercised too much caution in their pursuit of
contemplative prayer. Bickle stated:
“…our goal is to see you establish a vision to
go deep, deep, deep [into contemplative prayer] for five, ten, fifteen, twenty,
and thirty years, at a marathon pace. You’re going to need resources to do it.”
“…when I see ‘contemplative prayer’ in a book…
I buy it. I have maybe thirty, forty, fifty titles, closer to fifty of those in
my home. If I see any book on contemplative prayer, I buy it.”
“…I can’t find anyone I totally agree with… If
they have to be as perfect as you are, doctrinally, before you buy into
anything, you’re never, ever going to grow.”
“…those books… even… my favorites… they’re
still confusing and a little off, in my opinion. I know you’re thinking, ‘Well,
which is it?’ I believe there are errors in those books. I believe that they
were a little confused… Even with some of the errors and some of the confusion…
They have a lot more insight than I have…”
As we
close this section, it might be pointed out that some Christians assert Jesus
specifically warned against mantra meditation in Matthew 6:7, saying, “And
when you are praying, do not use meaningless repetition as the Gentiles do…”
1.
Mike Bickle, 7/19/2001, “Contemplative Prayer:
Session 1 Contemplative Prayer: Journey into Fullness”
2.
Mike Bickle, 7/20/2001, “Contemplative Prayer:
Session 2 Introductory Principles to Contemplative Prayer, Part 1”
3.
Mike Bickle, 7/21/2001, “Contemplative Prayer:
Session 3 Contemplative Prayer: Drawing Near to God”
4.
Mike Bickle, 7/22/2001, “Contemplative Prayer:
Session 4 Introductory Principles to Contemplative Prayer, Part 2”