Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 19 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
John Mark
Comer is a New York Times bestselling author of seven books, including his 2019
hit The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry. He served as the founding pastor
at Bridgetown Church in Portland, Oregon for nearly twenty years. In 2021, he
left the church to found a nonprofit ministry called Practicing the Way,
devoted to developing free spiritual formation resources for churches all over
the world.1 By early 2024, these resources were being used by thousands
of churches. 2 They focused on growth in nine Christian disciplines,
such as Sabbath, Prayer, Solitude, Fasting, and Scripture.3
Shortly
after completing the first draft of this book, the leaders of my Bible study
group announced that we were going to start working through John Mark Comer’s Practicing
the Way home group curriculum. In my curiosity to learn more about Comer, I
downloaded the free companion guides and read ahead. What I discovered in the Prayer
and Solitude companion guides was a supposed formula for hearing God’s
voice that included the most blatant endorsement of Eastern/New Age-style
meditation by a Christian leader I had ever encountered. 4
First,
Comer teaches his students to spend ten minutes every day sitting cross-legged
on the floor with a straight back and shoulders upright while inhaling deeply
through the nose for five seconds and exhaling through the mouth for five
seconds. He claims this is a God-ordained technique for calming the nervous
system and centering the mind. He recommends combining this breathing exercise
with a Christian mantra to help stay focused, such as “Jesus” or “Come Holy
Spirit.” He also suggests adding visualizations, such as imagining French doors
opening from within one’s body to invite God’s presence into the soul.
Second,
Comer briefly instructs his students to ask God to silence the voice of the
enemy, but provides no scripture to support his implication that this
guarantees protection.
As covered
in another article (“IS THERE A FORMULA FOR HEARING GOD’S VOICE”), scripture
offers no formula for hearing God’s voice that guarantees protection from the
enemy. This is true for at least three reasons. First, God is aware of our proneness
to finding security in following the right formula rather than in a genuine
relationship with Him. Second, God sometimes allows the enemy to remain present
as we journey through life in a fallen world that is subject to ongoing
spiritual battle. Third, the enemy may have a right to remain present in our
lives if there are parts of our heart that agree with him, even subconsciously.
In the
third step of his formula, Comer tells his students to ask God to speak to them
and trust that the very first thought that comes to mind is often from God. Examples
of ways God may speak, according to Comer, include a word or phrase, a
scripture, a picture or short film in the mind, a memory, or something one
recently thought about, read, heard, or saw.
Finally, Comer
tells his students to test what they hear against Scripture and in community.
As covered
in another article, evil spirits can speak biblical truth/counsel to gain trust,
and it is certainly possible for believers to mistake the enemy’s voice for God’s,
even when in community. Scripture records/warns that even genuine apostles and prophets
can potentially mistake the enemy’s voice for God’s.
How does
John Mark Comer rationalize endorsing an antibiblical prayer formula for
hearing God’s voice that is rooted in blatant New Age-style meditation? He
calls his formula the “Listening Prayer” or the “Beholding Prayer”
and claims it is based on 2 Corinthians 3:18, which states:
“But we all, with unveiled face, beholding as
in a mirror the glory of the Lord, are being transformed into the same image
from glory to glory, just as from the Lord, the Spirit.”
In the
verses prior, Paul explains that when a new convert turns to the Lord, Christ
removes the veil that was over his heart, blinding him to the truth. Then he
can behold Jesus with the eyes of his heart and be changed over time as he
walks in relationship with Him. Obviously, there is nothing in this passage
that endorses New Age-style meditation or a formula for hearing God’s voice.
As covered
in another article, if we are applying Eastern/New Age techniques to conjure
spiritual experiences on our own initiative, in violation of scripture, and
then asking the Holy Spirit to protect and bless us, we should absolutely fear
receiving a counterfeit. Further, Biblical meditation is merely setting one’s
mind on God’s word, law, works, or testimonies (ex. Psalm 1:2, 143:5, 199:99,
148). By contrast, New Age meditation seeks a spiritual experience by achieving
altered states of consciousness using techniques such as sensory deprivation,
stillness of mind, inward concentration, mantra repetition, and/or mental
visualization. Comer clearly promotes the latter.
1.
John Mark Comer Website, 2025, “About”
2.
Outreach Magazine, 1/2/2024, “John Mark Comer: The Apprentice”
3.
Christianity Today, 2/14/2024, “My Students
Are Reading John Mark Comer, and Now I Know Why”
4.
Practicing The Way Companion Guide, 2025, “Prayer,” “Solitude”