Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 9 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
During my years in the New Apostolic
Reformation, I was taught a handful of different prayer formulas for “hearing
God’s voice.” Such formulas are dangerous and deceptive for several reasons.
Let’s look at five.
Reason 1: God Does Not Use Formulas
First, authentic
supernatural experiences in scripture occur on God’s initiative (e.g. Acts
9:10, 10:9-10, 16:9, 18:9, 22:17-18, 2 Cor 12, Rev 1). This point alone is
totally incompatible with a prayer formula for hearing God’s voice on our own
initiative, terms, or timing.
God never
unceasingly works through formulas unless they are specifically prescribed in
the Bible, such as taking communion. He may give extra grace early on if a
believer is acting in naiveté, but eventually, He will stop, leaving a void
that can be quickly filled by an evil spirit posing as the Holy Spirit.
When God
stops working through a formula, this is for our good. The word formula is synonymous with tradition or ritual. Human beings have an incredible capacity to drift into
getting our sense of security and confidence from following the “right formula,”
which gradually replaces a real relationship with God without us even realizing
it. This is especially true of younger/newer Christians.
Reason 2: Our Imaginations Can Imitate God
Second, we
should never underestimate the capacity of the human heart to hear what it
wants to hear! Jeremiah 17:9 says:
“The heart
is more deceitful than all else and is desperately sick; who can understand
it?”
Furthermore,
we should never underestimate the capacity of the human heart to counterfeit
the voice of God. Our subconscious, or soul, can produce almost any type of experience,
impression, or sign we would typically interpret as being from God.
Accountability/community can help safeguard against this, but even this is not
without risk. For example, consider Jeremiah 23:16-32. God said of the
prophets:
“…they
speak a vision of their own imagination, not from the mouth of the Lord …[they] prophesy falsely in My name,
saying, ‘I had a dream, I had a dream!’ …[they]
prophesy …the deception of their own heart…”
This
passage repeatedly identifies these men as real “prophets,” not false prophets, that could have
been used by God if their hearts were right. This is why God said in the same
passage:
“But
if they had stood in My council, then they would have
announced My words to My people, and would have turned
them back from their evil way and from the evil of
their deeds…”
These
prophets clearly believed they were hearing from God or they would have fled
the city to escape the judgment Jeremiah tried to warn them about. However,
since their prophecies originated in their own imaginations, they ended up
opposing God by preaching a false message of peace and blessing rather than
repentance to avert calamity. If mistaking one’s imagination for God’s voice
was a danger for these authentic prophets, it certainly is for us as well.
Reason 3: Claims of Protection from the Enemy are Not Supported by
Scripture
Third,
scripture never promises that an evil spirit cannot deceive us when we ask God
to speak.
I
have heard several teachers/ministries
misapply scriptures to guarantee that only God will speak to
us when we ask Him to, and never an evil spirit. For
example, one taught that if you are afraid of being deceived, it means you have
more faith in the devil to deceive you than you have in the Holy Spirit to
guide you into all truth, referencing John 16:13. Another taught that if you
ask God for a word or experience from the Holy Spirit, He will never give you a
“snake” or “scorpion,” referencing Luke 11:11-13. Another taught that if you
rebuke the enemy in the name of Jesus, he has to flee from you, referencing
James 4:7.
There are
massive problems with these teachings. First, as stated previously, authentic supernatural
experiences in scripture occur on God’s initiative. By contrast, counterfeit
spiritual voices/experiences are typically conjured on our initiative, often
employing techniques that alter one’s state of consciousness such as sensory
deprivation, stillness of mind, inward concentration, mantra repetition, and/or
mental visualization.
Second,
sincerely trusting God to protect us from deception does not guarantee safety.
If we are heeding a false teaching that encourages us to conjure a spiritual voice/experience
on our own initiative, in violation of scripture, and then asking the Holy
Spirit to protect and bless us, we should absolutely fear receiving a
counterfeit. Correspondingly, scripture warns that sincere Christians can
absolutely become deceived both by false teaching and deceptive supernatural
experiences (e.g. Matthew 7:15, 24:4-5, 11, 24, 2 Corinthians 11:3-4, 13-15,
Galatians 4:8-11, Colossians 2:18-19, 1 Timothy 4:1-2, and 2 Peter 2:1-3).
Finally,
rebuking the enemy in the name of Jesus provides no guarantee of protection. We
will discuss this in more detail in the next two sections, but here we’ll
briefly comment on the misapplication of James 4:7, which says, “resist the devil and he
will flee from you.” Nothing in the context
of this passage suggests it is a method for eliminating the enemy’s voice from
a prayer time. Rather, James was confronting a group of believers who were
walking in severe, habitual sin. Therefore, he called them “adulteresses”
and rebuked them for “friendship with the world,” “hostility toward God,”
“quarrels,” “lust,” “murder,” “envy,” selfish “motives,” pride,
double-mindedness, judging (accusing) their neighbors, and excluding God from
their plans for the future. Thus, when James said “resist the devil and he
will flee from you,” he meant that they
should repent and stop succumbing to the enemy’s suggestions, which would cause
the enemy to lose his foothold in their lives.
Reason 4: God May Allow the Enemy to Remain Present
It is true
that there are passages of scripture in which Jesus or Christians rebuked
demons in a deliverance context and they fled. Examples include Mark 1:25,
9:25, Luke 4:35, and 9:42. Furthermore, many believers would say they have
experienced rebuking the enemy in prayer time, which resulted in a subsequent
lifting of oppression. I would include myself in this.
However,
many believers would also say they have experienced rebuking the enemy and he
remained present (again, myself included). This is not surprising since we see
examples in scripture of God specifically allowing the enemy to remain present.
We already noted that every believer can expect to be attacked with “flaming arrows of the evil one” (Ephesians 6:16). As another example, in 2 Corinthians
12:7-9, Paul said a “messenger of
Satan” tormented him and God refused to take it away.
Similarly,
Psalm 23:5 says God set a table before David “in the presence of [his] enemies.” Some may argue that this
refers to David’s human enemies. However, in verses 1-4, the passage is clearly
talking about God shepherding and protecting David’s soul, not his
physical life or political position.
Furthermore,
Mark 1:12-13 says, “the Spirit impelled [Jesus] to go out into the
wilderness… [where] He was… forty days being tempted by Satan.” In other
words, God specifically allowed Jesus to experience a season of temptation in
the enemy’s presence. This passage obviously refers to Jesus in His humanity
rather than His deity because James 1:13 says “God cannot be tempted by
evil.”
Reason 5: The Enemy May Have a Right to Remain Present
The enemy
may have a right to access us if we are living in agreement with him in some
area of our lives. For example, when Peter declared that he would never fall
away even if all the other disciples did (Matthew 26:33), there was pride and
self-reliance in his heart, which Satan had a right to exploit. This is why
Satan “demanded permission” to sift him like wheat (Luke 22:31), which
resulted in Peter soon denying that he even knew Jesus. We also previously saw
that believers can give the enemy a place of influence through actions such as
gossip (1 Timothy 5:13-15), dishonesty, resentment (Ephesians
4:25-26), and quarreling (2 Timothy 2:23-23).
This can
also be true even if our agreement is subconscious. Paul said in 1 Corinthians
4:4, “For I am
conscious of nothing against myself, yet I am not by this acquitted…”
We likely all have areas in our hearts that can be enticed to obey Satan’s
suggestions, even while thinking we are obeying God.
Examples of Mistaking the Enemy for God
Scripture
contains examples of people who sincerely thought they were hearing the Lord’s
voice but were really hearing the enemy or their own imagination. We already
examined Jeremiah 23:16-32. Here are some others:
·
In 1
Kings 22, four hundred prophets all mistook the voice of a “deceiving spirit” for the Spirit
of the Lord and prophesied accordingly. When another prophet, Micaiah,
correctly declared they had been deceived, one of four hundred was so offended,
he struck Micaiah on the cheek saying, “How did the Spirit of the Lord pass
from me to speak to you?”
·
Jesus
told the Pharisees in John 8:38-41, “you also do the things which you heard from your father,” referring to Satan. Yet the Pharisees sincerely replied: “we have one Father: God.”
·
In 1 Kings 13:15-25, a young prophet listened to the voice of an
older, more mature prophet because he mistakenly believed the man was speaking
the word of the Lord. In so doing, he disobeyed what God previously said to him
and it cost him his life.
·
Paul
tried to erect community safeguards against heeding imaginations or the enemy’s
voice by telling the believers to test one another’s words in 1 Corinthians
14:29-32, saying, “Let two or three prophets speak, and let
the others pass judgment… For you can all prophesy one by one,
so that all may learn and all may be exhorted; and
the spirits of prophets are subject to prophets…”
·
In
Matthew 16, Peter shared a revelation directly from the Father—that Jesus was the Christ. In
response, Jesus said, “…flesh and blood did not reveal this to you, but My Father who is in
heaven.” Just a short while later, Peter shared a revelation
directly from Satan—that
Jesus should not be killed. In response, Jesus said, “Get behind Me, Satan! You are a stumbling block to Me.”
Notice
that every one of these examples involves an apostle, experts of scripture, or
prophets. If mistaking one’s imagination or demonic counterfeits for God’s
voice was a danger for them, it certainly is for us as well.
Evil Spirits Can Speak Biblical Truth/Counsel to Gain Trust
When evil
spirits interact with believers, they frequently attempt to imitate the Holy
Spirit. Paul said in 2 Corinthians 11:14, “Satan disguises himself as an angel of
light.” In Matthew 7:15, Jesus depicted false prophets—who are empowered by evil spirits—as wearing
“sheep’s clothing,” which means they speak and act like sincere
Christians.
Imagine
you have a friend to whom you frequently go for counsel. Then imagine there is an
evil spirit with the power to physically appear in the form of your best
friend. The spirit mimics the same voice, mannerisms, clothes, and personality
of your best friend.
When your
friend gives you counsel, how would you know whether it was really him? It
would be difficult to discern under any
circumstances. However, knowing this spirit existed would be a good first step.
Then you could at least be on your guard.
This
illustration parallels our relationships with God. Because Christians are
targeted, I believe evil spirits study our personalities and the unique ways
God relates to us. They know what kind of promptings, suggestions, signs,
counsel, etc. we are likely to receive as being from God. Then they imitate
them.
“…a slave-girl having a spirit of divination…
kept crying out, saying, ‘These men are bond-servants of the Most High God, who
are proclaiming to you the way of salvation.’”
Why would
the spirit of divination promote the gospel and Paul’s ministry? It was laying
the groundwork for being considered trustworthy by the new/future converts of
Thyatira. Once it had their trust, it could begin gradually inserting deception
and leading them astray.
Spiritual Sensitivity Does Not Mean Clearer Guidance
Heightened
spiritual sensitivity does not give a believer an advantage when seeking
direction from the Lord. The enemy can counterfeit however we are used to God
speaking to us.
If a
believer typically makes decisions based purely on biblical wisdom and does not
believe in specific guidance, the enemy can pressure his or her mind to
misapply biblical wisdom to a specific situation. If a believer typically makes
decisions based on a gentle prompting, a sense of peace, an internal voice, a
mental impression, the counsel of a trusted friend or mentor, a dream, a
prophetic word, miraculously aligned circumstances, or some combination of
those things, the enemy can expertly counterfeit all those things as well. Even
if there was a believer who made decisions based on overtly supernatural
experiences, such as angelic visitations, this too could be counterfeited by
Satan.
Additionally,
we have discussed how our own souls/imaginations can imitate the ways God leads
us. This is especially true when seeking Him concerning something about which
we have strong emotions or biases. Then it is especially wise to seek counsel
from believers who are not emotionally invested in a particular outcome.
No matter
how mature we become and no matter how well we come to know God’s word or His
voice, we will never get to a point where we cannot be deceived. We will always
need prayer, humility, patience, wise counsel from godly friends/mentors, and
careful reliance on the Bible to discern how God is leading us.