Some people assert that treating others with kindness is more important than adherence to any particular religious/worldview doctrine. However, in some cases, this assertion is based on an underlying belief that having solid truth convictions and treating people with different convictions kindly are mutually exclusive. They aren’t. In fact, that’s the definition of tolerance. Tolerating another person’s beliefs doesn’t mean saying their beliefs are true. It means treating them with kindness and respect despite disagreeing. And it means respecting every person’s right to choose what to believe.

 

This, by the way, does not exclude proselytizing. For example, if two Muslim and Christian friends care about each other and sincerely believe they know the correct way to live in relationship with God, it is natural and commendable for them to try to respectfully persuade each other over time. This can absolutely be done with tolerance and kindness. Many people have relationships that could be characterized by this kind of tolerance. It’s not uncommon.

 

Some opponents of religion claim that any attempt to persuade someone to abandon their beliefs for another set of beliefs is offensive. However, this is only true when it is done with intolerance—that is, with unkind or disrespectful pressure, anger, or force. 

 

Unfortunately, intolerant proselytizing is common. It happens all over the world, with every major religion and worldview, including Christianity. There are countless instances in which people have tried to intolerantly force their views onto someone else. There are a number of reasons people do this. Here are five of them:

 

• Maybe they are sincerely concerned for the person’s soul and think intolerant pressure is justified.

 

• Maybe they are subconsciously insecure about their own beliefs, and it helps them feel more secure if they can persuade others to agree with them.

 

• Maybe they attribute certain evils in society to another worldview and feel a civic duty to oppose it.

 

• Maybe they look up to parents or clergy who have modeled that it is OK to intolerantly force their beliefs on someone.

 

• Maybe they have been taught that those who reject their worldview deserve to be mistreated.

 

I admit that I am guilty of intolerant proselytizing in my life due to more than one of these reasons. Nevertheless, for Christians, the Bible specifically commands the opposite. For example, 1 Peter 3:15 says to share one’s faith with gentleness and respect.

 

Obviously, we’re all human and we all make mistakes at times in how we relate to others, including how we share our deepest beliefs. But I don’t believe the answer is to reject any notion of absolute truth when it comes to religion or worldview. This is self-contradicting because it essentially claims that it is true that there is no truth and the beliefs of anyone who says otherwise are false. It’s nonsensical. Not to mention, there are plenty of intolerant people working to promote this view just like every other view. So, obviously, non-absolutism does not eliminate intolerance.