How could a loving God send someone to
hell? This is an important and common question. However, here is an equally
important question that is far less common:
How
could a loving God force someone to spend eternity with Him who does not want
to be with Him—someone who does not want to serve
Him, worship Him, or be morally accountable to Him?
The answer to that question is:
He doesn’t.
The essence of hell is separation from
God. God allows people to exist separately from Him because He created us with
free wills. He doesn’t force Himself on us, because He created us for voluntary
relationship with Himself.
What About Cultural Influences? What
About Those Who Have Never Heard?
Obviously, a large majority of people
on earth today and throughout history simply adopted the beliefs of their
parents or culture and did not make an informed, conscientious decision to
reject Jesus Christ as their savior. Many never even heard this message. God knows
this. He does not judge a Buddhist for being a Buddhist or a Muslim for being a
Muslim or an atheist for being an atheist, per se. He does not judge us for
things we have no control over, like the circumstances we were born into or the
influences that surrounded us. Rather, He judges us according to our choices—our
words, actions, thoughts, and motives—including how much truth we correctly understood
via our conscience and how we responded to it.
What About All the Good Things We Do?
It’s true that people are capable of
great compassion and kindness and love. The Bible says in Genesis 1 that God
made mankind in His image. Therefore, despite that image being distorted by
sin, we can still reflect His righteous attributes at times. Jesus said in Luke
6 that the default disposition of sinful human beings is to love those who love
them and to do good to those who do good to them. The Greek used for love is agape,
referring to selfless, sacrificial love.
Likewise, Romans 2 says that God’s
moral law is, to some extent, written on every person’s heart. Therefore, our
consciences alternately defend or accuse us. When we do something kind or
generous, we might subconsciously feel, “I’m a good person. Look at what I
just did.” When we do something we know is wrong, we might
subconsciously feel, “I can’t believe I did that. I’m so awful.”
In other words, the Bible says every
person who has ever lived has two things in common:
1)
Every
person sincerely wants, tries, and succeeds in being a
morally good person some of the time.
2)
Every
person fails to be a morally good person, even according to their own
standard of goodness, at least some of the time.
Does the Bible’s assessment on these
two points sound accurate to you?
Illustration #1: The Floating Screen
Despite our acts of goodness, no
amount of sincere intention or discipline can change the basic, self-serving
nature of the human heart. This may sound cynical, but it is actually pretty
intuitive and easy to verify using some simple illustrations or thought
experiments. Let’s consider three.
Imagine you wake up one morning and,
to your amazement, there is a two-dimensional screen floating above your head
that follows you everywhere you go, and that everyone can see. As you go about
your day, the screen portrays everything going on inside you that you would
normally keep hidden. When your sloppy, irritating roommate promises once again
he’ll clean up the mess he made three days ago, you smile and thank him, but
the screen shows your angry face yelling, “F*** you! Will you please just
move out!” When you greet your attractive married colleague at work, the
screen displays pornographic images of her. When your highly-paid boss who was
promoted ahead of you calls you into his office, the screen depicts you calling
him an incompetent moron and punching him in the face.
Now imagine going through your whole
life like this. It would be like going through life naked, except with your
thoughts and motives exposed instead of your body. How would this impact your
relationships with family members, friends, co-workers, and acquaintances?
Now consider that this would arguably
be the most authentic, transparent version of you. Doesn’t it say something
about our condition that a primary way we attempt to maintain harmonious
relationships is by frequently hiding the truth of what’s really going on
inside us?
This illustration depicts what God
sees. God sees all of our thoughts and motives, even our subconscious ones. That
by itself would be alarming enough, but God is also completely unlike us. He is
perfectly, morally pure and selfless. Therefore, He views evil with much
greater severity than we do. In His eyes, lust is like adultery. Hatred and
revenge are like murder. Greed and jealousy are like theft. Pride and
self-righteousness are like self-worship. And so forth. This is also because
thoughts and motives are the precursors to outward action. Jesus said in
Matthew 15:19-20:
“For
out of the heart come evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts,
false witness, slanders. These are the things which defile the man…”
Now consider that, according to the
Bible, reliving our whole lives from the floating-screen perspective I
described is exactly what will happen. The Bible says when we are judged
for our lives on earth, we will see all of our words, actions, thoughts, and
motives from God’s perspective (e.g. Ecclesiastes 12:14, Matthew 12:36, Romans
14:10, 1 Corinthians 3:13-15, 1 Corinthians 4:5, 2 Corinthians 5:10, Revelation
20:12, 22:12). It also says in Romans 3 that when this happens, every person’s
mouth will be shut. No one will make excuses. No one will object that he isn’t
being judged fairly. We will fully understand how incapable we were of
deserving God’s acceptance on our own merits.
The weight of our immoral words,
thoughts, and actions will be unimaginable in that context. Some scholars
believe it will actually be much more tolerable for the lost to be separated
from God in hell than to remain in His presence with the full weight of their
sins still upon them. However, in the case of the believer, that sin is taken
off of him and put onto Jesus Christ on the cross. This is the remedy God
provided. This is how God can be both just in His condemnation of sin and yet
merciful to sinners, with no contradiction.
Possibly the best way for a person to
realize he needs a Savior is to honestly contemplate what God will see on the
floating screen of our hearts on the Day of Judgment. But this is the last
thing we want to do because we subconsciously fear exposure of our true
condition. This is why Jesus said in John 3:19-20:
“…Light
has come into the world, and men loved the darkness rather than the Light, for
their deeds were evil. For everyone who does evil hates the Light, and does not
come to the Light for fear that his deeds will be exposed.”
Illustration #2: Unlimited Power
Here’s another thought experiment.
How old were you the first time you stole
something? Or the first time you told a lie? I was around four years old. Most
people I’ve talked to say the same thing. So, lying and theft come early and
naturally to people. It’s in our nature.
Some people argue that most adults
don’t steal or lie anymore, which shows they’ve learned from their mistakes and
become better people.
I’m not sure if I agree that most
adults stop lying or stealing in one form or another. But even for those who
do, in many cases, it’s only because they’ve learned the costs outweigh the
benefits. For example, maybe they’ve learned to be afraid of what will happen
if they get caught. Or maybe they’ve learned that lying or stealing would
obstruct their need to feel like a good person or to not feel weighed down with
guilt.
However, if you were to change the
conditions, they might show their underlying nature has not changed. For
example, how many people would steal $100 million if they knew for sure they
could never be caught? I bet the vast majority of people would. If I’m correct,
this would show those people still have the nature of a thief, but they just
haven’t been provoked by the right conditions to act on it.
You could also change the conditions
to make it easier on the person’s conscience. For example, what if the $100
million theft only resulted in the loss of one dollar for 100 million
upper-middle-class people, or from several huge corporations, so no individual
would be seriously hurt by the theft? Perhaps then an even a larger majority of
people would go for it.
The same sort of thought exercise
could be done with other vices, such as murder or revenge or lust or pride.
What if you had the power to make someone you loathe painlessly disappear,
including everyone else’s memory of that person—like the perfect murder? What
if you had the power to miraculously produce some other form of retribution
toward someone you were mad at without anyone ever tracing it back to you? What
if you had the power to override another person’s free will and make them love
and admire you or obey you or sexually desire you? What if you had the power to
instantly make yourself smarter or more attractive or more talented than anyone
else in the world?
I can’t honestly imagine myself or
anyone else not becoming completely corrupted by such temptations. We really
can’t fully know the potential for evil in our hearts unless we could somehow
remove all the restraints that keep us from fulfilling it. However, God does
fully see the true condition and potential of our hearts, yet He loves us
anyway enough to die and suffer in our place. This is why Romans 5:6-8 says:
“For
while we were still helpless, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly.
For one will hardly die for a righteous man; though perhaps for the good man
someone would dare even to die. But God demonstrates His own love toward us, in
that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.”
There is a reason that it is a
universally acknowledged truism that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts
absolutely. This is not an observation about power as much as it is an
observation of the corruptibility of the human heart.
God, by contrast, possesses infinite
power, and yet He is infinitely good and selfless. He is not like us and we are
not like Him. This is why our only hope of being reconciled to Him is through
His mercy rather than our own moral performance. The Bible says in Galatians 2
that if it were possible to earn God’s acceptance through moral performance,
then “Christ died needlessly.”
Illustration #3: Good Deeds Can Make Our
Situation Even Worse
Here’s another
illustration.
When I was four years old,
I stole a few dollars’ worth of quarters from my dad’s home office. For the
next two days, I felt sick with guilt. However, I was afraid to tell my dad the
truth, so I secretly brought the money in my pocket to church the next Sunday
and put it in the offering, hoping to alleviate my guilt.
It seemed to work. I began
to feel better. I reasoned to myself that I was not a bad person since I
ultimately gave the money away to a holy cause.
Ironically, the pastor of
the church saw me put the money in the offering and mailed a letter to my
parents praising their son’s virtuous character! When my parents read it and
began telling me how proud they were of me, I knew I was a fraud.
Whenever
we do good things that are motivated, even subconsciously, to appease
underlying guilt or to convince ourselves or others that we are good, this is
actually an affront to God. Not only does this not bring us closer to God, it
pushes Him farther away. Just like giving that stolen money to the church
pushed my dad away because it just took me deeper into hiding the truth from
him.
When
we do good things to appease underlying guilt or to convince ourselves or
others that we are good, the Bible calls this “dead works.” Dead works
are at the foundation of every false religion and worldview, including humanism
and some forms of Christianity. Even atheists want to feel like good people and
often expend a tremendous amount of effort in pursuit of it.
In
a sense, there are only two belief systems in the world. True religion, which
is based on God’s mercy and a restored relationship with Him. And false
religion, which is based on dead works.
These two religious systems are
represented at the beginning of the Bible by the Tree of Life and the Tree
of Knowledge of Good and Evil. The reason the second tree was called that
is because, after the first man and woman disobeyed God and their fellowship
with Him was broken, they felt guilty and began spending their lives trying to
justify themselves according to their knowledge of good and evil.
Every person has followed this pattern
ever since. We all do things we know are wrong, then we do good things to
compensate for the guilt we feel, or to demonstrate to ourselves that we’re
still good people, which makes the problem even worse! It’s a spiritual death
cycle. This is why Hebrews 6:1 says leaving dead works behind is the “foundation”
of Christianity.
By contrast, the Tree of Life
represents a restored relationship with God by trusting in Jesus Christ’s death
on the cross for our sins to save us. Again, by Jesus’s death on the cross, God
showed Himself to be both just in His condemnation of sin and yet merciful to
sinners, with no contradiction. When we accept that we are loved and forgiven
by God apart from our merits, it sets us free from trying to justify ourselves
with dead works.
Why Can’t We Make Ourselves Acceptable
to God?
Many people ask: What if someone
sincerely tries to live a good, ethical life and treats people with kindness? Wouldn’t
this make a person acceptable to God?
Personally, I think the three
illustrations we’ve seen so far—1) the floating screen, 2) unlimited power, and
3) dead works—discredit the notion that anyone lives a truly good/ethical/kind
life. Such a life may be achievable from a superficial, human perspective, but
not from the perspective of a morally perfect God who sees every thought and
motive of our hearts.
Furthermore, underlying the question—Why
can’t we make ourselves acceptable to God—is the belief that a person can
outweigh the bad with the good.
Again, trying to outweigh the bad with
the good is just another form of dead works, which is at the foundation of nearly
every false religion and worldview, including secular humanism. This belief
asserts that a person can earn one or more of the following through sincere
moral effort or performance:
·
A
righteous moral standing
·
God’s
acceptance
·
A
positive afterlife
·
Entrance
into heaven
·
Avoidance
of hell
·
A
positive reincarnation
We’ve talked about salvation versus
dead works in terms of 1) two religious systems, and 2) two trees in the Garden
of Eden. As a final illustration, let’s imagine two continuums.
The first continuum says “Bad
People” on one side and “Good People” on the other. Everybody on
earth and throughout history falls somewhere along that continuum and their
position determines their moral standing and/or afterlife situation. This is
the default human view, and it is a deception.
The second continuum says “People
Who Think They Are Righteous” on one side and “People Who Know They Are
Not” on the other. The people closest to the first side can never be
saved because something inside them is deeply offended at the suggestion that
they need to be saved. By contrast, the people who know they are not
righteous can potentially be saved if they seek God’s mercy in humility by
putting their faith in Jesus Christ.
This is the continuum that Jesus
explained in the Bible (e.g. Matthew 5:1-7, 19:16-26, Luke 18:9-14). This is
the truth.
Probably the most famous sermon in world
history is the Sermon on the Mount that Jesus gave in Matthew Chapter 5. The very
first words out of His mouth were:
“Blessed
are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.”
In other words: Blessed are those
who acknowledge they are spiritually bankrupt, because this is the first step toward
reconciliation to God. Jesus goes on in that same chapter to explain why
every person is spiritually bankrupt before God—because He sees anger as murder,
lust as adultery, and so on.
I have watched online or
personally participated in probably hundreds of conversations with random
people on the street who were asked some variation of the question, “If
there is a heaven, do you think you will go there after you die?” I’d
estimate over 90% of the people responded with some variation of the answer, “Yes,
because I sincerely try to be a good person and treat others with kindness.”
Outweighing the bad with the good is a
very human idea—meaning it didn’t originate from God.
Since the vast majority of people in
the world sincerely think they are good people, and yet the world is in a dark
and corrupt state, doesn’t it make sense that the universally popular view on
moral goodness might be false and the universally unpopular, fringe view might
be true?
Returning to Cultural Influences and
Those Who Have Never Heard
Earlier we acknowledged that a large
majority of people on earth today and throughout history simply adopted the
beliefs of their parents or culture and did not make an informed, conscientious
decision to reject Jesus Christ as their savior. Many never even heard this
message.
So, is it even possible for someone
who has never really heard or understood the gospel to be saved? If not, how is
that fair?
This is an important question. As a
preface, first remember that fairness, or justice according to God’s
standard, is the default for everyone. The only people who will not be treated fairly,
so to speak, are those who receive unmerited mercy.
But to the first part of the question,
all Christians agree and the Bible confirms that there were people who lived
before Jesus Christ—or even before any of the Bible was written—that were saved
without knowing the specifics of the gospel message. So how were they
saved? The answer is two parts.
First, they were saved by their
response to what they did accurately understand about God.
Second, their response included these
three elements:
1)
Humility. They acknowledged their need for
God’s forgiveness.
2)
Faith. They trusted in God’s mercy rather
than their own moral performance to save them from His just judgment.
3)
Repentance. They sincerely sought to walk in
relationship with God and turn away from patterns they knew were wrong in His
eyes.
Can these same essentials save people
who have no knowledge of the gospel after Jesus Christ lived? In a
sense. I think that if anyone steadfastly seeks to implement these essentials
into their lives, God responds by communicating the gospel to them, either by
sending someone to share it, or by supernatural means—similar to how God saved
Cornelius in Act 10, both by giving him a vision and by sending Peter to preach
the gospel to him.
I have heard numerous testimonies by
Christians to whom God communicated the gospel through a dream, a vision, or an
angelic visitation. For example, I met a former Muslim from Iran who shared how
his wife came to Christ after having a dream of Him calling her to follow
Him. Testimonies like this seem particularly prevalent in parts of the
world that are either unreached by the gospel or where Christianity is subject
to state-sponsored persecution.
How Can I Be Saved?
If you are reading this and have not
put faith in Jesus Christ to save you from your sins and restore you into
relationship with God, you can do so right now. God sees you, hears you, knows
your thoughts, and is present with you right now. You can speak to Him. Let me
walk you through three steps. The first two you can take right now. The third
will take the rest of your life.
Step one: Acknowledge your need for
God’s forgiveness. Step two. Put your faith in Jesus’s payment for your sins on
the cross and in God’s mercy rather than your own moral performance to save you
from His just judgment. You can say this to God out loud right now from your
heart:
“God,
I know I am a sinner. I know I need your forgiveness. I know I can never save
myself from your just judgment with my best attempts at moral performance. I
believe You sent Your Son Jesus Christ to die on the cross for my sins because
you love me. I receive Your free gift of forgiveness and eternal life with You.
Thank you for saving me.”
If you prayed that prayer,
congratulations—you now belong to God’s family!
You have just entered through “the
narrow gate.” Jesus said in Matthew 7:13-14:
“Enter
through the narrow gate; for the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads
to destruction, and there are many who enter through it. For the gate is small
and the way is narrow that leads to life, and there are few who find it.”
As Jesus said, the path to eternal
life is both a narrow gate and a narrow way. The narrow gate is the initial
decision to give your life to Christ, which you just made. The narrow way is
walking in relationship with Jesus Christ for the rest of your life. This is
step three.
To follow the narrow way, there are
only three things you need:
1)
Prayer
2)
God’s
Word
3)
God’s
people
Prayer is talking to God. Do this
often, every day if possible. Common elements of a prayer time include praise
(thank God for who He is, what He has done, and what He means to you),
entreaties (ask God to help you become the man or woman He created you to
become), confession (ask God to forgive you if you are aware that you have
sinned recently), and intercession (pray on behalf of others who need God’s
help).
God’s Word is the Bible. He has given
it to mankind to reveal who He is and what He has done. Read at least one
chapter often, every day if possible. Start with the gospels and continue
through the New Testament. Pray for God to give you understanding as you read.
God’s people are Christians.
Immediately find a church nearby to attend. Pray for God to guide you to the
right church. It should be a church that believes the Bible is the inspired
Word of God and teaches directly out of it every week. Then introduce yourself
and develop relationships with men and women who have walked with God for years
who can help you on your journey.
If you are afraid that you might
stumble into sin, don’t worry. You will.
If you are afraid you don’t have what
it takes to remain faithful to your commitment to Christ for years and decades
to come, don’t worry. You don’t.
If you are afraid that Satan is much
smarter and more powerful than you, and you aren’t strong enough to overcome
him, don’t worry. You aren’t.
The only thing you need to do is: Keep
turning to God!
It does not matter how badly you
stumble, how far you fall, or how long you stray. God will never give up on you
or stop loving you. Just keep turning to Him. Just keep turning to prayer, His
word, and His people. If you do this, He will bring you safely into His
heavenly kingdom. It will be His accomplishment, not yours. Because He loves
you. And “love never fails” (1 Corinthians 13:8).