When scripture says God “hardened” a person or group, it does not necessarily mean overriding free will. In some contexts, it means God gave them a revelation of His nature, character, or existence that He knew they would reject. In so doing, He provoked them to continue all the more swiftly down the path they were already headed.

 

John Chapter 12 is a good example of this. Shortly before Jesus’ arrest and crucifixion, John quoted Isaiah’s prophecy, saying in verse 40:

 

“He has blinded their eyes and He hardened their heart, so that they would not see with their eyes and perceive with their heart, and be converted and I heal them.”

 

Taken out of context, this verse seems bizarre—as though God did not want these Israelites to be saved. However, in context, we see two things.

 

First, they had already witnessed countless signs before this. Verse 37 says, “…though He had performed so many signs before them, yet they were not believing in Him.”

 

Second, they had all just heard God audibly speak from heaven. In verse 28, the Father said audibly, “I have both glorified it, and will glorify it again.”

 

So, giving them one last sign by speaking audibly from heaven was how God effectively “blinded their eyes” and “hardened their heart.” By confronting them with one last supernatural sign, He forced them to choose one last, culminating rejection of Jesus’ ministry.

 

Also, notice the other Isaiah prophecy that John 12 quoted, immediately after saying the Israelites still didn’t believe despite seeing so many signs. Verse 38 quotes Isaiah as stating:

 

“Lord, who has believed our report? And to whom has the arm of the Lord been revealed?”

 

This is the question God continually asked of the Israelite population throughout Jesus’s ministry. However, after they made their choices and became polarized, the Father spoke from heaven as a final sign that “blinded” and “hardened” some, but no doubt provided further confirmation and softening to those who believed. Hence, Jesus said in verse 30:

 

“This voice has not come for My sake, but for yours.”

 

One man’s hardening is another man’s softening—it depends on how his heart responds to God.

 

More Examples of Miracles Hardening Hearts

In the last section, we saw how when the Father audibly spoke to Jesus, many of the people hardened their hearts and denied it, saying it thundered (John 12:29). Likewise, when Jesus raised Lazarus from the dead, some of the people went and told the Pharisees rather than surrender their hearts to Him (John 11:46). Similarly, when the Pharisees witnessed Jesus miraculously restore a man’s withered hand, they conspired how they might kill him (Matthew 12:14). Clearly, being exposed to hard evidence of God at work in their midst was not beneficial to every person’s soul.

 

Consider the Israelites in the book of Exodus. They witnessed God bring the most powerful empire on earth to its knees with a series of cataclysmic plagues. They witnessed Him part an enormous body of water so they could safely pass through and then close it back in upon their pursuers. They witnessed Him supernaturally provide food and water. They witnessed Him lead them with a cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night. They witnessed Him descend on Mount Sinai in blazing fire, thunder, lightning, and thick clouds.

 

It is unlikely that any Christian alive today has as much first-hand experience of God as the average Israelite of that generation. Yet they still rebelled to such an extent that God came to the brink of annihilating them over and over (ex. Exodus 32:14, Deuteronomy 9:13-25, Psalms 106:23, Numbers 11:1-2, 14:12-20, 16:20-35, 41-48). 

 

People are judged according to how much light they have been exposed to and how they respond to it. This is why Jesus said in Luke 12:48:

 

“From everyone who has been given much, much will be required; and to whom they entrusted much, of him they will ask all the more.”

 

This is also why Jesus said Capernaum would be judged more severely than Sodom even though Sodom appeared far more wicked on the outside. Jesus knew the men of Sodom would have repented if they had received the same level of light that Capernaum did (Matthew 11:24).

 

This is also why Moses, who regularly spoke with God face to face, was disqualified from entering the Promise Land for one outburst of anger (Numbers 20), or why Ananias and Sapphira were struck dead for misrepresenting their generosity during a great revival (Acts 5).

 

There is a higher level of accountability for those who are given experiences that diminish the need to exercise faith in God’s existence, character, or power.

 

Even though witnessing miraculous signs removes intellectual barriers to faith, it does not remove the inclinations of our hearts to go on living for ourselves. Therefore, if we do go on living for ourselves despite our experiences, the enemy’s access to our lives grows much greater since we are much more accountable. Sin and hard-heartedness can actually increase rather than diminish.

 

Therefore, God is careful in how He brings along a person or group into greater first-hand revelation of Himself. He does not give more than we are able to respond to wisely. Sometimes it is better for Him not to give us overt, miraculous proof of His involvement in our lives, but to give us the opportunity to trust Him by faith.

 

Perhaps this is why Jesus repeatedly connected sign-seeking with wickedness and spiritual adultery (Matthew 12:39, 16:4, Mark 8:12, Luke 11:29). For example, in Luke 11:29-32, when the Pharisees and the crowds asked Jesus for a sign, He replied that the only sign they would receive was the anointed words coming from His mouth. He reminded them of Jonah, whose preaching was so powerful that it caused one of the wickedest civilizations on earth to repent without any accompanying signs or wonders. And he reminded them of Solomon, whose words were so wise that a foreign queen traveled a great distance to hear them.

 

The Pharisees and crowds to whom Jesus spoke had already witnessed so many signs that it would only have hardened them further if He acquiesced to their demand for a sign. The apostle Paul likewise trusted the Holy Spirit to anoint His preaching of the gospel rather than acquiescing to counterproductive demands for signs. He stated in 1 Corinthians 1:22-23:

 

“For indeed Jews ask for signs… but we preach Christ crucified…”

 

Why Jesus Spoke in Parables

Incidentally, this is also why Jesus often spoke in parables when He addressed large crowds. He knew that teaching certain truths explicitly would unnecessarily/prematurely harden many of His listeners. This is why Mark 4:33 says:

 

“With many such parables He was speaking the word to them, so far as they were able to hear it…”

 

Jesus used parables as a way of fishing for men. He showed them the bait and waited to see who would respond by seeking Him for understanding afterward. This is clearly stated earlier in Mark 4, alongside yet another quotation of Isaiah’s blinding/hardening prophecy from John 12:40 (although here it uses slightly different wording). Look at Mark 4:10-12:

 

“As soon as He was alone, His followers, along with the twelve, began asking Him about the parables. And He was saying to them, “To you has been given the mystery of the kingdom of God, but those who are outside get everything in parables, so that while seeing, they may see and not perceive, and while hearing, they may hear and not understand, otherwise they might return and be forgiven.”

 

So, we see three factors present in Mark 4:

 

·         Jesus spoke the word to large crowds in parables “so far as they were able to hear it…”

·         Jesus waited for the crowd to leave until only “His followers” (distinct from the twelve disciples) remained before explaining the meaning of the parables.

·         Jesus quoted Isaiah’s blinding/hardening prophecy and applied it to those who did not care enough to stay behind and seek Him further for understanding.

 

Thus, the parables acted like a sieve that divided Israelites who were ultimately hardened by Jesus’ message from those who were softened. Again, one man’s hardening is another man’s softening.

 

Why God Hardened Israel

Now it is true that the majority of Israel (as a corporate entity, not specific individuals) was predetermined to reject Jesus, as we see in some biblical passages, such as Romans 9-11. (Romans 9-11 will be discussed in more detail elsewhere.) However, what I’ll mention here is that, when Paul described God “partially hardening” (Romans 11:25) Israel, so gentile remnants could be “grafted in” (Romans 11:17) to salvation God’s salvation plan, it does not mean He overrode their free wills. It simply means He revealed Himself through Jesus in such a way and to such an extent that He knew most of them would reject Him.

 

It might also be noted here that when Paul said in Romans 11:7 that the Israelites “who were chosen obtained it [salvation], and the rest were hardened,” the Greek word for “chosen” comes from the same root as the word used by Jesus when He said in Mathew 22:14, “Many are called, few are chosen.” In other words, there is a difference between being “called” to salvation and being “chosen” for salvation. The latter depends on how an individual responds to God’s call. (Revelation 17:14 also distinguishes between being “called” and “chosen”.)

 

God partially hardened Israel (without overriding individual free will) in order to save as many souls as possible, not only in Jesus’ generation but throughout the course of history. This is precisely why Paul summarized his discourse in Romans 11:25-35 by saying:

 

“For I do not want you, brethren, to be uninformed of this mystery… that a partial hardening has happened to Israel until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in… For just as you once were disobedient to God, but now have been shown mercy because of their disobedience, so these also now have been disobedient, that because of the mercy shown to you they also may now be shown mercy. For God has shut up all in disobedience so that He may show mercy to all.”

 

If we view Paul and Jesus’ generation in isolation, God’s sovereignty temporarily worked against the spiritual welfare of ethnic Israel. However, Romans 11 is clear that in the ages to come we will recognize how this choice was ultimately in the best eternal interests of both the Jews and gentile nations.

 

The Unimaginable Choices God Must Make

While God’s choice in Jesus’ generation temporarily worked against ethnic Israel, He made many choices in previous generations that worked to their benefit. For example, look at what God said to Israel in Isaiah 43:4:

 

“Since you are precious in My sight, since you are honored and I love you, I will give other men in your place and other peoples in exchange for your life.”

 

Wow. In generations before the cross, God handed over entire nations and people groups into eternal perdition in order to preserve a believing remnant among His chosen nation.

 

God has made choices that we cannot imagine having to make. Since He has chosen to respect our free wills, the reach of His grace depends, to some extent, on human agreement (via prayer, faith, and obedience). Therefore, He must at times make choices about how, where, and when to apply that grace. He may have to choose between sending His grace to one nation and not sending it to another nation, knowing that perhaps millions of additional souls will be saved from one and lost from the other in the decades or centuries that follow. Is this not essentially what God said He did in Isaiah 43:4?

 

In fact, God even named the nations He traded away in the previous verse, saying, “I have given Egypt as your ransom, Cush and Seba in your place.” I do not believe this means that any specific individual in those nations was inevitably damned with no possibility of being saved. However, it does mean that God knew the overall trend of those nations would be to descend into wickedness, resulting in the vast majority being damned.

 

Isaiah’s use of the words “ransom” and “exchange for your life” allude to the involvement of a third party who is demanding a ransom payment. This party, we could surmise, is Satan. Satan continually demands access wherever he thinks he is legally entitled to it. For example, Satan “demanded to sift [Peter] like wheat” in Luke 22:31-33 because there was pride and self-reliance in his heart. Likewise, Revelation 12:10 says Satan “accuses” believers to God, day and night. Similarly, in Zechariah 3:1-5, Satan stands beside Joshua the high priest “to accuse him” before God.

 

Of course, God has the power to hold Satan back and give an individual or nation more time, mercy, and grace to repent. But if they persist in rebelling long enough, there comes a point when God says to Satan, “You’re right. They don’t want to repent. You may now lay ahold of the authority they have chosen to give you.” Thus, Satan presumably demanded permission to lay ahold of Israel in Isaiah 43:3-4 and God acknowledged that he was legally entitled to do it. However, rather than giving Satan what he demanded, He gave him increased access to three other nations instead.

 

Israel at times was no more righteous or obedient than the surrounding nations, despite having far more understanding of what God required. Nevertheless, it was given special grace and mercy that other nations were not. Why? One reason was “for the sake of the fathers” as Paul said in Romans 11:28. The seeds of faith and obedience sown by men such as the patriarchs, Moses, Joshua, and David continued to yield a harvest of grace to their descendants long after they died. Perhaps we too can live before God in such a way that extra grace will be shown to our children and grandchildren if they go astray.