In Part 1, we discussed the first
three origin questions, which are:
1.
Where did our time/space/matter/energy universe come from?
2.
Where did a finely tuned environment that can potentially support life come
from?
3.
Where did the first life come from?
New Species Appearing Is Irrelevant to
Evolution Vs. Creationism
In this article, we’ll discuss the
last major origin question: Where did the diversity of life on earth come from?
This question has been conclusively
answered by overwhelming evidence for evolution, right? Even today we observe
new species spontaneously appearing in nature.1,2,3 What more proof
do you need?
Actually, new species appearing is
completely irrelevant. This is because standard genetics tells us that new
species not only can appear, but they inevitably will appear due
to speciation, which has nothing to do with either proving evolution or
debunking creationism.
The major classifications in animal
taxonomy are: 1) Domain, 2) Kingdom, 3) Phylum, 4) Class, 5) Order, 6) Family,
7) Genus, 8) Species.
The family classification is
the typical starting point for genetic diversity in the creationist model. Take
the Felidae (cat) family, for example, which includes all breeds of tigers,
leopards, jaguars, lions, panthers, cougars, small cats, and domestic cats.
Now, let’s say you begin with just one
genetically diverse male and female member of the cat family. If their
descendants periodically disperse into isolated breeding populations in
different environments, climates, terrains, and ecological conditions, this
would eventually produce countless different cat species that are radically
diverse from one another in terms of body size, skeletal structure, coat color/pattern/length,
metabolism, vision, behaviors, etc.—just as diverse as tigers, leopards,
jaguars, lions, panthers, cougars, small cats, and domestic cats.
You wouldn’t even necessarily need
much time for this to occur.
Have you ever heard that old trick
where you ask someone whether they would choose $1000 today or one just penny
today, two pennies tomorrow, four pennies the next day, and so on for 30 days?
Most people choose the $1000, but if
you choose the pennies, after 30 days you would have over a billion pennies (over
ten million dollars). If you continued the pattern to 40 days, you would have
over a trillion pennies (over a hundred billion dollars). And so on. That’s the
power of exponential growth.
The same is true of animal
reproduction. Of course, animal numbers are limited by what the available
habitats can sustain, but nevertheless, under the right conditions, the
potential for genetic diversification in even just a few dozen generations is
staggering.
Terms such as natural selection,
gradualism, gene flow, genetic recombination, genetic
drift, and genetic mutations all refer to known processes that can
contribute to speciation within animal families.
All of them are observable and
established by the scientific method.
And all of them have nothing to do
with debunking creationism.
New species emerging, and all the
mechanisms by which this happens, is compatible with evolution, but it
does not prove evolution any more than it proves creation.
Outdated Claims that Creationism Has
Been Debunked
It is worth noting here that,
unbeknownst to him, Darwin’s theory of evolution was rooted in a scientific
field—genetics—that didn’t exist when he proposed the theory. In fact, it has
only been in the last 20-30 years that animal genomes have begun to be mapped.
Thus, the evolutionary model for biodiversity (as well as the creationist
model) has only begun to be examined at the genetic level.
So, why do we sometimes read about new
species appearing as proof of evolution? This is something that creationist
scientists complain about—evolutionists debunking arguments they have not made
for decades or, in some cases, over a century, while never addressing their
current arguments.
For example, Harvard geneticist and
creationist, Dr. Nathaniel Jeanson, wrote a book called Replacing Darwin,
which explained the aforementioned Felidae speciation example, among other
concepts.4 After publishing the book, he gave an open invitation for
evolutionary biologists to debate him on the content. The invitation was
accepted by Dr. Herman Mays of Marshall University.
In his opening statement, Dr. Mays
brutally attacked Dr. Jeanson as a pseudo-scientist and then attempted to
debunk what he apparently thought were several claims that Dr. Jeanson promoted
in his book. Every time, Dr. Jeanson responded by asking Dr. Mays to specify
where he found those claims in the book, which Dr. Mays couldn’t do because the
book didn’t contain any of them.5
Dr. Jeanson later stated that Dr. Mays
displayed almost no evidence of having read the book at all, despite claiming
to have read it twice. In subsequent interviews, Dr. Jeanson pointed out that
it is illegal in the United States for public schools to teach
intelligent-design-related concepts, which is why most scientists have never
considered speciation with created animal families to explain our planet’s
biological diversity.
How Would Evolution or Creationism Be
Incontrovertibly Proven/Debunked?
Incontrovertibly debunking creationism
and/or proving evolution in accordance with the scientific method would require
observing either the emergence of a new animal family by evolutionary processes
or one animal family converting into another (such as a dog species evolving
into a cat species), neither of which has ever been observed. And whatever paleontologists
assert the fossil record establishes, the hard evidence for such an event
resides in the DNA sequences. In fact, over 99% of an animal’s biology is found
in the soft tissue. Fossils do not and cannot constitute observable,
incontrovertible evidence for debunking creationism and/or proving evolution in
accordance with the scientific method.
Furthermore, even if we set this aside
and look for such evidence based only on hard skeletal structures, the fossil
record runs into a gargantuan problem known as the Cambrian Explosion or the
Biological Big Bang.
The reason it is called the Biological
Big Bang is because virtually all major animal phyla (which is three taxonomy
classifications above family) appear in the fossil record suddenly and
fully formed—not gradually or in stages.6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13 How is
this possible?
Interestingly, in 2018, a team of
nearly three dozen scientists published a paper in Progress in Biophysics
and Molecular Biology positing that the Biological Big Bang occurred as the
result of… you guessed it: alien seeding! The study focused largely on
Cephalopods due to their genetic material supposedly being able to survive
travel through space, but the larger takeaway was that life on earth appeared
to defy unaided terrestrial evolution, in their assessment. The paper’s
abstract stated:
“In
our view the totality of the multifactorial data and critical analyses
assembled by Fred Hoyle, Chandra Wickramasinghe and their many colleagues since
the 1960s leads to a very plausible conclusion… living organisms such as…
fertilised ova and seeds have been continuously delivered… to Earth… which has
resulted in considerable genetic diversity and which has led to the emergence
of mankind.”14
One Thousand Ph.D.’s Dissent
The apparent inability of evolution to
account for the earth’s biodiversity beyond speciation within animal families likely
explains the wording chosen by the “Scientific Dissent from Darwinism”
statement, which over one thousand Ph.D.’s in scientific fields have publicly
endorsed. The statement reads:
“We
are skeptical of claims for the ability of random mutation and natural
selection to account for the complexity of life. Careful examination of the
evidence for Darwinian theory should be encouraged.”
The signatories include about 180
biologists, 250 chemists, and 120 doctors of medicine. It also includes about
450 university professors (approximately 100 of whom are professors of biology,
chemistry, or medicine).15
Nevertheless, the National Academy of
Sciences responded with this demonstrably false statement:
“…there
is no debate within the scientific community over whether evolution occurred…
scientists continue to debate only the particular mechanisms that result in
evolution, not the overall accuracy of evolution as the explanation of life’s
history.”16
Ironically, National Academy of
Sciences member and Penn State Chemistry professor Philip Skell is one of the
Dissent from Darwinism signatories.
The Dissent from Darwinism website
asserts the list exists in response to efforts by some to “deny the
existence of scientific critics of Neo-Darwinism and to discourage open
discussion of the scientific evidence for and against Neo-Darwinism.”
The website adds that signing on to
the statement does not imply endorsement of any alternative theory, such as
intelligent design or creationism. For example, the New York Times interviewed
atheist and Brooklyn College Biology Professor Stanley Salthe, who said he
signed because evolutionary biologists were unfairly suppressing any competing
ideas and they deserved and to be prodded.17
A number of criticisms of the Dissent
from Darwinism list have been voiced. Let’s take a look at several. One is
not well-supported. A few are valid but need qualification. One is irrelevant
to the core issue, which is that no evolutionary process has ever been observed
to cause the emergence or conversion of any animal family, much less the
higher taxonomy classifications.
The New York Times ran a derisive
article in 2006 asserting that “many” of the signers were evangelicals.
While this could theoretically be true, the article offered no percentage
estimate and the claim was based on interviews of just twenty of the
signatories, of whom “some” or “several” were evangelicals. The
twenty interviewees accounted for less than 5% of the signers at the time.
The article also argued that only a
quarter of the signers were biologists, whose field is most directly concerned
with evolution. This is a valid point, although it could also be added that any
science-based Ph.D. can easily grasp the core issue that no evolutionary
process has ever been observed to cause the emergence or conversion of any
animal family, much less the higher taxonomy classifications.
The National Center of Science
Education called the wording of the statement “spin” and “misleading” because
it only mentioned natural selection and mutations and didn’t name any other
mechanisms such as gradualism, gene flow, genetic recombination, or genetic
drift.19 However, this criticism is irrelevant to the core issue
since these terms all refer to processes that are known to occur within
families, but have never been observed to cause the appearance or conversion of
any animal family, much less higher taxonomy classifications.
In his 2015 book, Basics in
Evolution, evolutionary biologist Michael Muehlenbein pointed out that the
Dissent from Darwinism statement was created by the Discovery Institute, which
promotes intelligent design and creationist ideas. This point is worth raising.
However, as stated, signing on to the statement does not imply endorsement of
any alternative theory, including intelligent design or creationism.
Muehlenbein also pointed out that the
sum total of the signers accounted for well under 1% of the total number of
Ph.D.’s in the world that are qualified to sign it if they chose.20
This point is also worth raising, although it includes no information about
what percentage of those qualified individuals is, one, aware of the list’s
existence and, two, aware of the core issue it raises.
Has the Majority Ever Been Wrong?
Nevertheless, to Muehlenbein’s point,
it’s fair to say that only a small minority of biologists and other scientists
express skepticism of evolution’s ability to fully explain earth’s biodiversity.
This raises an important question: Is
it theoretically possible for a large majority of experts in a given field to
be wrong?
The answer to this question is
obviously yes and there are many examples we could point to.
For example, it can happen with
governments and intelligence experts, taking many nations to war based on
information that turns out to be completely false.21
Or it can happen with economists and
financial experts, who somehow fail en masse to detect massive structural
problems that plunge the world into a global recession.22
And it can happen with scientists as
well.
While scientists enjoy the highest
public trust of any group of professionals23,24,25, the trust is
arguably not well deserved.
For example, in 2005, Stanford
Professor of Medicine John Ioannidis showed that most published research
findings are false because they are framed to satisfy confirmation bias.26
Further, in 2012, a major study of
over 2000 retracted scientific articles found that the large majority were
retracted not because of error, but because of misconduct, plagiarism and
fraud.27,28,29
Further still, in 2013, another major
study of over 1,500 scientists uncovered a major “crisis of reproducibility”
in which the majority of published and supposedly verifiable findings by
scientists could not be replicated.30,31,32,33
The fact is that scientists, like all
other field experts, are human beings that are subject to confirmation bias,
worldview bias, normalcy bias, group think, peer pressure, career advancement
pressures, self-preservation, and at times just plain dishonesty and
corruption.
This certainly includes the field of
evolutionary biology, as was powerfully illustrated by what was once considered
possibly the most important scientific discovery in world history. In 1912, the
New York Times heralded that some of the world’s foremost evolutionary
biologists had finally found definitive proof of the long-sought missing link
between apes and mankind. The human skull with an apelike jaw was dubbed
Piltdown Man and was estimated to have lived 750,000 to 950,000 years ago.34
The incredible fossil was introduced
as proof of evolution during the infamous 1925 Scopes Monkey Trial.35
United States public school children were taught that Piltdown Man conclusively
proved Darwin’s theory for more than forty years. And over 500 scientific
papers were written on it.36
There was just one problem: Piltdown
Man was an abject fraud.
The teeth were filed down to make them
look human. The jaw was boiled and stained to make it look older. Jaw and skull
fragments were planted at the excavation site.37,38,39 The ultimate
science conspiracy theory was, in reality, just a conspiracy. And all of the
world’s foremost scientists were none the wiser.
Public Education
Let’s return for a moment to the topic
of public education. Many evangelical Christians have asserted that intelligent
design or creationist concepts should be taught alongside evolution in biology classrooms.
In response, a number of reputable scientific organizations have vehemently
protested the notion.40
For example, the American
Anthropological Association has stated:
“Science
describes and explains the natural world: it does not prove or disprove beliefs
about the supernatural.”
The American Astronomical Society has
stated:
“Science
is not based on faith, nor does it preclude faith… the teaching of important
scientific concepts… should not be altered or constrained in response to
demands external to the scientific disciplines.”
The National Association of Biology
Teachers has stated:
“Explanations
or ways of knowing that invoke non-naturalistic or supernatural events or
beings… are outside the realm of science and not part of a valid science
curriculum.”
The Geological Society of America has
stated:
“Science,
in contrast, is based on observations of the natural world. All beliefs that
entail supernatural creation… fall within the domain of religion rather than
science. For this reason, they must be excluded from science courses in our
public schools.”
The Paleontological Society has
stated:
“…creationism
is religion rather than science… because it invokes supernatural explanations
that cannot be tested.”
In my opinion, these are valid points.
As a Christian, I’d say the sciences are the study of what God has created, but
the actual act of God creating something out of nothing defies science by
definition, as we discussed in Part 1.
However, as we also saw in Part 1,
some of the world’s top secular scientists have no problem acknowledging the
appearance of design in one-celled organisms as long as the designer is
speculated to be an alien race. Yet it is certainly no less scientific to
speculate that the designer of one-celled organisms is the same designer
responsible for time, space, matter, energy, and the finely-tuned laws that
govern them. So, what precludes this point from being raised in science
textbooks? Only an illogical naturalistic/materialistic worldview bias.
Furthermore, science should play by
its own rules. If science really is based on observations of the natural world
and testable explanations (as we just saw that the Geological and
Paleontological Societies asserted), then science textbooks should be radically
altered in their discussions of origins.
There is no evolutionary biologist on
earth who has argued or would argue that mankind has observed in real-time the
emergence of any animal family (or conversion of one animal family into
another) by evolutionary processes, much less the higher taxonomy
classifications.
While some paleontologists claim the
fossil record shows this, in reality the fossil record shows not only all families
but virtually all phyla appearing suddenly and fully formed, in seeming
defiance of evolutionary explanations.
Thus, science has not conclusively
answered the question of how animal families originated, much less the higher
classifications. This is a glaring gap in the scientific body of knowledge, and
science textbooks should acknowledge it.
Science textbooks should also not
claim without evidence that all life evolved from single-celled organisms. And,
going back to Part 1, they certainly should not claim without evidence that
single-celled organisms spontaneously arose from a primordial soup via chemical
evolution. Neither of these assertions is based on observations of the natural
world or testable explanations. Hence, they are unscientific.
Closing
The Paleontological Society is correct
that science cannot test or study supernatural causes. However, this also
logically means science does not have the ability to rule out supernatural
causes until a natural cause has been conclusively identified.
Science has not identified a natural
cause for the existence of our time/space/matter/energy universe.
Science has not identified a natural
cause for the existence of a finely tuned environment that can potentially
support life.
Science has not identified where the
first life came from.
And science has not identified where
animal families and higher taxonomy classifications came from.
Therefore, it has not ruled out a
supernatural cause for any of these things.
Furthermore, science will never
rule out supernatural causes. Even if we met the aliens that seeded the first
cells and traveled to the parallel universes that explained the life-enabling
properties of our planet and universe, we still wouldn’t have proven the first
clue about where those aliens and universes came from.
If there is no God, why is there
something instead of nothing? Even an eight-year-old can understand that logic.
1.
New
York Times, 11/14/2022, “While Other Insects Played, This Species Evolved
the Blade”
2.
Scientific
American, 12/18/2011, “Evolution: Watching Speciation Occur”
3.
BBC,
11/23/2017, “Galapagos Finches Caught in Act of Becoming New Species”
4.
Dr.
Nathaniel Jeanson, 2017, “Replacing Darwin: The New Origin of Species”
5.
Dr.
Nathaniel Jeanson and Dr. Herman Mays, 9/25/2018, “Nonsequitur Presents
Replacing Darwin: A Debate on Origins”
6.
New
York Times, 9/17/1993, “Biology’s ‘Big Bang” Took A Mere Blink of the Eye”
7.
Nature,
2/16/2016, “What Sparked the Cambrian Explosion”
8.
Natural
History Museum, 2/19/2019, “The Cambrian Explosion Was Far Shorter Than We
Thought”
9.
Budd,
G. E.; Jensen, S., 2000, “A Critical Reappraisal of The Fossil Record of The
Bilaterian Phyla”
10. Budd, G.E., 2003, “The Cambrian
Fossil Record and the Origin of the Phyla,” pgs. 157-165.
11. Steven Gould (Harvard Biology
Professor), 1977, “Evolution’s Erratic Pace,” pgs. 13-14
12. Jonathan Well, 2000, “Icons of
Evolution: Science or Myth? Why Much of What We Teach About Evolution is
Wrong,” pg. 37
13. Norman Geisler and Frank Turek, 2004, “I
Don’t Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist,” Chapter 6
14. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular
Biology (Volume 136, August 2018, pages 3-23), 2018, “Cause of Cambrian
Explosion—Terrestrial or Cosmic?”
15. See:
https://dissentfromdarwin.org/
16. American Civil Liberties Union,
undated, “What the Scientific Community Says About Evolution and Intelligent
Design”
17. New York Times, 2/21/2006, “Few
Biologists but Many Evangelicals Sign Anti-Evolution Petition”
18. Ibid.
19. National Center of Science Education,
2/26/2016, “Doubting Darwinism Through Creative License”
20. Michael Muehlenbein, 2015, “Basics
in Evolution”
21. U.S. Senate Select Committee on
Intelligence, 7/7/2004, “Report on the U.S. Intelligence Community’s Prewar
Intelligence Assessments on Iraq” (Conclusion 3)
22. Foreign Affairs, November/December
2013, “Never Saw It Coming,” by Alan Greenspan
23. YouGovAmerica, 2/8/2021, “Scientists
and Doctors Are the Most Respected Professions Worldwide”
24. Pew Research Center, 9/29/2020, “Science
and Scientists Held in High Esteem Across Global Publics”
25. Guardian, 8/2/2019, “Scientists Top
List of Most Trusted Professions in US”
26. Public Library of Science (PLOS)
Medicine, August 2005, “Why Most Published Research Findings Are False,”
by John P. A. Ioannidis
27. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences Journal, Vol. 109, No. 42, 10/1/2012, “Misconduct Accounts for the
Majority of Retracted Scientific Publications”
28. Guardian, 10/1/2012, “Tenfold
Increase in Scientific Research Papers Retracted for Fraud”
29. Guardian, 9/5/2011, “Publish-Or-Perish:
Peer Review and the Corruption of Science”
30. Phys.org, 9/20/2013, “Science Is in
a Reproducibility Crisis: How Do We Resolve It?”
31. Nature, 9/25/2016, “1,500
Scientists Lift the Lid on Reproducibility”
32. Economist, 10/1/2013, “How Science
Goes Wrong”
33. Washington Post, 8/27/2015, “Many
Scientific Studies Can’t Be Replicated. That’s A Problem.”
34. New York Times, 12/22/1912, “Darwin
Theory Proved True”
35. New York Times, 5/26/1925, “Scopes
Is Indicted in Tennessee for Teaching Evolution”
36. Time, 11/30/1953, “Science: End as
A Man”
37. Time, 3/16/2010, “Top 10 Shocking
Hoaxes: Pack of Lies; Piltdown Man”
38. LiveScience, 12/8/2021, “Piltdown
Man: Infamous Fake Fossil”
39. BBC, 2/17/2011, “Piltdown Man:
Britain’s Greatest Hoax”
40. American Civil Liberties Union,
undated, “What the Scientific Community Says About Evolution and Intelligent
Design”