The four major origin questions are:
1.
Where did our time/space/matter/energy universe come from?
2.
Where did a finely tuned environment that can potentially support life come from?
3.
Where did the first life come from?
4.
Where did the diversity of life on earth come from?
Evolution only purports to address the
last question. Setting evolution aside for the moment, there are valid
arguments for the first three origin questions pointing to the existence of
God.
The Big Bang Had a Supernatural Cause
by Definition
First, where did our
time/space/matter/energy universe come from?
Most scientists agree that the
evidence indicates the universe had a beginning, called “The Big Bang”. If
that’s true, it means time, space, matter, energy, and the natural laws that
govern them did not exist prior to the Big Bang. This means the cause of the
universe was outside of time, space, matter, energy, and natural laws, which,
by definition, means the cause was supernatural—outside of
nature.
In other words, science supports the
idea that the universe had a supernatural cause.
A simple yet profound question worth
asking is: If there is no God, why is there something instead of nothing?
Finely-Tuned for Life
Second, where did a finely tuned
environment that can potentially support life come from?
Scientists have identified well over a
hundred life-enabling constants with very small margins for error that are
present on earth or in the universe that are necessary to sustain life.
Examples include the earth’s oxygen level, atmospheric transparency,
interaction with the moon, carbon dioxide level, water vapor level, crust
thickness, rotation speed, and on and on.
The odds of every necessary condition
occurring simultaneously for any single planet are astronomical, no pun
intended. Christian astrophysicist named Hugh Ross calculated it as roughly 1
in 10^138, which is more than the total number of atoms in the entire universe.1
Some prominent atheists and agnostics
have also made statements to the effect that the earth and universe at least
give the appearance of being designed to support life. For example, Cambridge
astrophysicist Fred Hoyle famously said:
“A
commonsense interpretation of the facts suggests that a super intellect has
monkeyed with physics, as well as chemistry and biology, and that there are no
blind forces worthy speaking about in nature.”2
Likewise, the famous atheist author
Christopher Hitchens, who won the Richard Dawkins Award for exemplary
contributions to secularism and rationalism, stated on camera:
“At
some point, certainly, we are all asked which is the best argument you come up
against from the other side. I think every one of us picks the fine-tuning one
as the most intriguing… It’s not a trivial [argument]. We all say that.”3
Similarly, Cambridge physicist,
author, and SETI chairman Paul Davies has said:
“There
is now broad agreement among physicists and cosmologists that the Universe is
in several respects ‘fine-tuned’ for life… rather it is fine-tuned for the
building blocks and environments that life requires.”4
Some have argued that the Many-worlds
theory, which is one interpretation of quantum mechanics, renders the
fine-tuning argument moot, since there are potentially an infinite number of
other universes that are not finely tuned.
However, the Many-worlds theory is
under ongoing debate, and it is not based primarily on the scientific method
where one conducts measurable experiments to test hypotheses. In fact, some
scientists consider it unfalsifiable and therefore unscientific because the
proposed parallel universes are defined in such a way that no information can
be passed between them.5,6
The Origin of First Life
Third, where did first life come from?
The simplest form of life on earth, a
one-celled organism, is incredibly complex. It’s like a factory full of
delicate instrumentation, communication systems, transport systems, defense
systems, production and assembly systems, quality control and repair systems,
etc. On top of all this, the DNA message in every cell is equivalent to the
complexity of 1,000 encyclopedias.
The process by which first life is
theorized to have arisen on earth is “chemical evolution,” in which a
fully functioning, self-replicating cell naturally developed through unguided
chemical processes. However, life has never been observed to spontaneously
arise from non-life even in the most sophisticatedly idealized conditions
contrived in laboratories by top scientists, much less in nature. And due to
the cell’s immense complexity, a growing number of scientists are acknowledging
the enormous challenges this theory faces.
The cell’s breathtaking complexity has
led some secular scientists to consider that an advanced alien race may have
designed and seeded life on earth. For example, biophysicist Francis Crick, who
won the Nobel Prize for deciphering the helical structure of the DNA molecule,
first proposed this idea in the 1960s.7,8
Since then, numerous papers and
articles in publications such as Scientific American and National Geographic
have discussed the possibility.9,10,11
Likewise, in 2008, the famous atheist
and Oxford evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins stated:
“It
could be that at… somewhere in the universe a civilization evolved… to a very,
very high level of technology and designed a form of life that they seeded on
to perhaps this planet… it’s possible that you might find evidence for that if
you look at the at the detail of biochemistry, molecular biology, you might
find a signature of some sort of designer.”12
Further, in 2013, various mainstream
and scientific publications covered a paper in which scientists claimed to have
found a “signature” like the one Dawkins mentioned. The paper’s summary says:
“…the
proposal that [life] might have been seeded intentionally cannot be ruled out.
A statistically strong intelligent-like ‘signal’ in the genetic code is then a
testable consequence of such a scenario. Here we show that the terrestrial
[DNA] code displays a thorough precision-type orderliness matching the criteria
to be considered an informational signal.”
“Simple
arrangements of the [DNA] code reveal an ensemble of arithmetical and
ideographical patterns of the same symbolic language. Accurate and systematic,
these underlying patterns appear as a product of precision logic and nontrivial
computing… The signal displays readily recognizable hallmarks of artificiality
[i.e. design]…”13,14,15
Of course, these sources don’t say
anything about God, only aliens. But the point is that life on earth gives the
appearance of having been intelligently designed. Many secular scientists
philosophically rule out a supernatural cause as impossible prior to examining
any evidence. Richard Dawkins and Harvard Evolutionary Biologist Richard
Lewontin, for example, have said as much outright.16,17 So that
really leaves aliens as the only possibility they are able to consider.
Some have argued that perhaps we just
haven’t discovered the answer yet and when you begin explaining things you
don’t presently understand with “God did it,” you move away from science and
into religion. You resort to “God-of-the-gaps.” It’s a cop-out.
However, in this case we’re talking
about acknowledging positive evidence for intelligent design. This is not
resorting to “God-of-the-gaps” any more than the scientists we’ve mentioned are
resorting to “aliens-of-the-gaps.”
Review
Let’s review what we’ve covered. The
four major origin questions are:
1.
Where did our time/space/matter/energy universe come from?
2.
Where did a finely tuned environment that can potentially support life come
from?
3.
Where did the first life come from?
4.
Where did the diversity of life on earth come from?
Regarding question one, we learned
that science supports the idea that the universe had a supernatural
cause.
Regarding question two, we learned
that the odds of every necessary condition to sustain life occurring
simultaneously for any single planet are astronomical.
Regarding question three, we learned
that the simplest form of life on earth is incredibly complex, seems to defy
chemical evolution explanations, and gives the appearance of having been
intelligently designed, which has prompted some leading scientists to theorize
alien-seeding.
Clearly, evolution does not disprove
God since it only purports to address the last question. But what about
question four? Has evolution fully explained the diversity of life on earth?
We’ll address this question in Part 2.
1.
Norman
Geisler and Frank Turek, 2004, “I Don’t Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist,”
Ch. 4, pg. 106
2.
Fred
Hoyle, “The Universe: Past and Present Reflections.” Engineering and
Science, November 1981. pp. 8-12
3.
Lee
Strobel and Mark Mittelberg, 2019, “The Miracles Answer Book,” Chapter
16
4.
Smith,
W. S., Smith, J. S., & Verducci, D., eds., Eco-Phenomenology: Life,
Human Life, Post-Human Life in the Harmony of the Cosmos
(Berlin/Heidelberg: Springer, 2018), pgs. 131-32.
5.
Bunge,
M. (2012). “Parallel Universes? Digital Physics?”. Evaluating
Philosophies. New York: Springer. pp. 152-153.
6.
Ellis,
G.; Silk, J. (2014). “Scientific method: Defend the integrity of physics”.
Nature. 516 (7531): 321-323.
7.
Crick,
F. H.; Orgel, L. E., 1973, “Directed Panspermia,” pgs. 341-48.
8.
New
York Times, 6/26/2007, “Human DNA, the Ultimate Spot for Secret Messages
(Are Some There Now?)”
9.
Scientific
American (blog), 10/15/2012, “The Panspermia Paradox”
10. National Geographic, 9/5/2013, “Did
Life on Earth Come From Mars?”
11. Paul Davies, 2010, “The Eerie
Silence: Renewing Our Search for Alien Intelligence”
12. Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, Premise Media, 2008, Richard Dawkins
Interview
13. Vladimir Cherbaka and Maxim Makukovb,
2/17/2013, “The ‘Wow! Signal’ of the Terrestrial Genetic Code”
14. Huffington Post, 4/9/2013, “ET
Genetic Code May Be Found In Human DNA, According To Kazakhstan Scientists’
Biological SETI Theory”
15. Evolution News, 3/12/2013, “In the
Planetary Science Journal Icarus, the ‘Wow!’ Signal of Intelligent Design”
16. Norman Geisler and Frank Turek, 2004, “I
Don’t Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist,” pg. 122 (quoting an e-mail
response by Richard Dawkins)
17. The New York Review of Books,
1/9/1997, “Billions and Billions of Demons,” by Richard Lewontin