Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 18 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
Bethel’s
endorsement of New Age witchcraft disguised as Christian spirituality is
perhaps best illustrated by examining the two books covered in this article.
The 2015
book, The Physics of Heaven, was carried for years by Bethel’s bookstore.
It is endorsed by Bethel and written, in part, by Bethel staff members. For
example, the forward is written by Bethel’s senior pastor and “prophet” Kris
Vallotton. The introduction and Chapter 1 are written by Bill Johnson’s
administrative assistant (who also teaches at Bethel’s ministry school) Judy
Franklin. Chapters 4 and 16 are written by Bethel’s senior pastor and “apostle”
Bill Johnson. Chapter 15 is written by Bethel’s former senior pastor (and Bill’s
late wife) Beni Johnson.
A major
theme of the book is that there is something new, secret, or hidden about
Christianity that is waiting to be discovered. For example, in the forward,
Kris Vallotton calls the contents of the book:
“…a divine invitation to join these
supernatural explorers… [who are] leaving the safe haven of conventional
thinking…”
Likewise,
the preface to Chapter 4, written by Bill Johnson, states:
“…there are whole realms of insights that
belong to the people of God we’ve failed to explore… [Bill Johnson] emphasizes
how crucial it is for us to recover lost ‘God truths’…
Further,
Bill Johnson exhorts:
“God is saying, ‘There are mysteries to be
understood… they’re there for the taking.’”
“Discovering the ‘secret things’ that God has
left for us has to matter. I believe one of the keys is for us to come to the
place where we recover lost mysteries of God…”
In Chapter
15, Bill’s wife Beni Johnson says:
“…God is issuing a clarion (a shrill and clear
sound) calling us to venture into new realms, including realms of the
vibrations of heaven.”
The book
also teaches that God is about to restore these secret mysteries to the church
through a second Pentecost that will surpass the Pentecost of scripture. For
example, the preface to Chapter 3 by “prophet” Bob Jones states:
“In this chapter, Bob Jones shares that God is
beginning… to prepare us for a second Pentecost that… brings us into harmony
with God.”
Likewise,
in Chapter 10, Larry Randolph states:
“I believe we are on the verge of experiencing
Pentecost on a new level and in a new measure… we still await… a ‘fullness of
Pentecost’ for which the original Pentecost provided the down payment.”
God’s Secret Mysteries Come from the New Age Movement?
At this
point, you might be asking, what exactly are these secret mysteries that
Christians can discover? What are these hidden truths God is about to restore
to the church?
Answer:
They are certain “precious” practices and beliefs of the New Age Movement!
If you are
skeptical, listen to their own words and judge for yourself. Chapter 2 states:
“…all of the Christian leaders who contributed
to this book… agree that the next move of God will cause a shift… that the New
Age movement has been exploring. They also all agree that there are precious
truths hidden in the New Age that belong to us as Christians and need to be
extracted…”
Do I
exaggerate? Similarly, in Chapter 10, Larry Randolph states:
“Perhaps the most significant thing we can do…
is to start recovering the truths that are currently held… by many unbelievers.
Many New Agers, for example, have already begun… to ‘tune in’ to multiple
realms of spiritual reality. In a small measure, many have succeeded in this
spiritual quest.”
False Rationalization #1: Jeremiah 15
You might
wonder how professing Christian leaders rationalize teaching Christians to
extract “precious truths hidden in the New Age.” There are two answers
to this question, both of which are remarkably anti-biblical. The first answer
comes from Ellyn Davis, author of Chapters 2, 6, 11, and 12. It is based on a
blatant misinterpretation of a passage in Jeremiah 15, as we will see
momentarily. The opening to Chapter 2 explains that Davis has “a desire to…
discover God truths hidden in… the New Age.”
By way of
background, Davis recalled that in 2006, she moved to Sedona, Arizona—“the global epicenter of New Age thought and practice.” She
attributed the job she was offered there to “God’s inexplicable sense of
humor.” She then explains:
“I saw… mystical experiences and revelations
to rival anything I had seen or experienced in the church… I just wanted to
find out if maybe they had uncovered some truths the church hadn’t.”
“At that time, I could not find a single
Christian leader who shared a similar interest in finding out if there were
truths hidden in the New Age. Now we are beginning to hear more and more
revelation that is in line with what New Agers have been saying all along…”
“…there are a few courageous Christians who
are beginning to speak up and say, ‘Wait a minute, there may be some God truth
there that really belongs to us and that we should know about!’”
Now back
to the question: How does Davis rationalize delving into New Age teachings and
practices in search of “God truths”? She quotes Jeremiah 15:19 as
stating:
“If you extract the precious from the
worthless, you will become My spokesman.”
She then
concludes:
“We may have to delve into areas we previously
considered off-limits to extract the ‘precious’ from the ‘worthless’ and
recover lost truths that belong to the people of God.”
Is this a
correct interpretation or application of Jeremiah 15:19? No honest Bible
student who briefly examines the passage in context could possibly believe
this.
In
Jeremiah 15, God had called Jeremiah to declare His coming judgment upon Judah
(vs. 1-14). At first, Jeremiah was delighted to be God’s spokesman (vs. 16).
However, as a result of this calling, Jeremiah began to experience persecution,
reproach, and alienation (vs. 15, 17-18). When he complained to the Lord about
how difficult this was, God replied:
“If you return, then I will restore you—before Me you will stand; And if you extract the precious from
the worthless, you will become My spokesman. They [Judah] for their part
may turn to you, but as for you, you must not turn to them.”
In
context, the “precious” refers to the part of Jeremiah’s heart that
wanted to obey God and fulfill God’s purpose for him no matter what the cost.
And the “worthless”
refers to the part of Jeremiah’s heart that wanted the approval of his
countrymen and felt bitter about being persecuted.
Clearly,
this passage has nothing whatsoever to do with hidden spiritual practices used
by pagans that God wanted His people to discover and begin pursuing.
False Rationalization #2: We Should Study Counterfeits
As stated,
the book also provides a second rationalization for teaching Christians to
extract “precious truths hidden in the New Age.” The rationalization
goes like this:
New Age beliefs and practices are counterfeits
of authentic Christian beliefs and practices. Therefore, we should study the
counterfeits to learn about the authentic versions.
The
rationalization comes primarily from Jonathan Welton, author of Chapter 5. As
we will see in Chapter 26, in the 2010s Jonathan Welton founded a supernatural
ministry school and then sexually groomed and abused several of his young
female staff members. He was also diagnosed as an extreme worst-case
narcissistic sociopath. However, when Bethel leader Danny Silk was brought in
to oversee Welton’s accountability process, Silk tried to minimize/cover-up
Welton’s abuse, conceal his diagnosis as a sociopath, and eventually restored
him back into ministry over the objections of every other member of the
accountability board, which Silk unilaterally dissolved.
The
opening of the Chapter 5 states:
“Jonathan Welton teaches that whenever there
is a real, there is sure to be a counterfeit. We shouldn’t be afraid to examine
the counterfeits…”
“Jonathan tells us that we need to be much
more concerned about reclaiming all of our stolen goods from the enemy…”
In the
body of the chapter, Welton further states:
“If there is a counterfeit, there is an
authentic that we need to find and reclaim. Every time we see a masquerade, we
need to look closely to properly discern what is being counterfeited, because a
counterfeit is evidence that an authentic exists.”
“Therefore, if we see a counterfeit, we must
test it and find out what it counterfeits so we can reclaim the
authentic.”
“Consider taking this as a personal challenge:
If you see a counterfeit, use it as a signpost that points to the authentic.”
Before we examine the two Bible passages Welton distorts to
rationalize this position, it must be pointed out that his reasoning is
illogical, even by his own standards. As Welton himself correctly
asserts:
“The best way to spot a counterfeit is to
become an expert of the authentic.”
In other
words, the primary way to spot unbiblical (including New Age) beliefs and
practices is to carefully study God’s word to develop biblical beliefs and
practices.
Study the
authentic to expose the counterfeit.
Yet this
is exactly the opposite of what Welton promotes: Study the counterfeit to learn
about the authentic. It is dangerously nonsensical.
Welton’s
counsel is also the opposite of what scripture teaches. For example, when
Israel was preparing to enter the promised land, God specifically instructed
them not to learn the pagan beliefs and practices of its inhabitants. He said
in Deuteronomy 12:29-30 and 18:9-11:
“When the Lord your God cuts off before you
the nations which you are going in to dispossess… beware… that you do not
inquire after their gods, saying, ‘How do these nations serve their gods, that
I also may do likewise?’”
“When you enter the land which the Lord your God gives you, you shall not
learn to imitate the detestable things of those nations. There shall not be
found among you anyone who… uses divination, one who practices witchcraft, or
one who interprets omens, or a sorcerer, or one who casts a spell, or a medium,
or a spiritist, or one who calls up the dead.”
God did
not say anything about precious truths hidden in their pagan practices that
could be extracted by the Israelites to experience more of God. Similarly, when
a great revival took place in Ephesus in Acts 19, scripture specifically
connects God’s word being magnified and the destruction of countless valuable
books that taught magic. Acts 19:19-20 states:
“And many of those who practiced magic brought
their books together and began burning them in the sight of everyone; and they
counted up the price of them and found it fifty thousand pieces of silver. So
the word of the Lord was growing mightily and prevailing.”
According
to Welton’s thinking, the apostle Paul made a terrible mistake to allow such a
destruction. He should have encouraged the Ephesian believers to study the
magic books in search of new God truths!
Welton
cites 1 Thessalonians 5:21 to falsely rationalize his position. He quotes it
(apparently from the Evangelical Heritage Version) as stating:
“Test everything. Hold on to the good.”
He then
claims:
“Therefore, if we see a counterfeit, we must
test it and find out what it counterfeits so we can reclaim the authentic.”
However,
in context, Paul is talking specifically about testing prophetic utterances.
Verses 20 and 21 together state:
“Do not treat prophecies with contempt. But
test everything. Hold on to the good.”
Further,
verses 12-15 make clear that, in this part of his letter, Paul is talking
specifically about practices within the Thessalonian church community. So, Welton
takes Paul’s exhortation to the Thessalonians to carefully examine prophecies
given within the safe boundaries of their church community and then claims what
Paul really meant was to investigate pagan spiritual practices in search of new
Christian truths. Disgusting.
Welton
also quotes John 10:1 as stating:
“I tell you the truth, the man who does not
enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief
and a robber.”
He then
applies this passage in the following way:
“Spiritual practitioners who access and
operate in the spirit without Jesus as the Lord of their lives are trespassers
in the spirit realm… It is dangerous to operate in spiritual realms without
being in right relationship with the Lord… We must go into the sheepfold
through the gate, which is Jesus Christ.”
John 10:1 is
the beginning of Jesus’s beloved parable of the Good Shepherd. Sheep symbolize
God’s people and a gate symbolizes a legitimate, rightful access point to God’s
people through Jesus Christ. This interpretation is plain from the passage and
is universally agreed upon by Bible teachers. Welton’s claim that the passage
is actually about accessing spiritual experiences is an appalling distortion of
Jesus’s words.
Seven New Age Practices We Should Reclaim?
Most of
the time, The Physics of Heaven is remarkably vague about what exactly
is meant by phrases such as “lost God truths,” “secret things [of] God,”
and “lost mysteries of God.” However, Welton briefly names seven New Age
beliefs/practices as being counterfeits that need to be reclaimed and exercised
by the church. He states:
“With all this talk about counterfeit and
authentic, by now you may be… hoping for examples. The best examples I have
found are in the New Age Movement. They have been trafficking in the church’s
stolen goods for a long time.”
“I have found throughout Scripture at least 75
examples of things that the New Age has counterfeited, such as having a spirit
guide, trances, meditation, auras, power objects, clairvoyance, clairaudience,
and more. These actually belong to the church, but they have been stolen and
cleverly repackaged… Now whenever you see a counterfeit, I hope you will ask
yourself… How can I have the authentic?”
Once
again, Welton’s reasoning is illogical, even by his own standards. As Welton
himself correctly asserts:
“…the only thing [Satan] can do is take
something that God has created and distort it into something different… than it
was originally meant to be.”
Well said.
And the crucial distortion that Welton fails to mention is that authentic,
biblical supernatural experiences occur on God’s initiative while counterfeits
are conjured through practicing witchcraft techniques. Therefore, by
encouraging readers to actively “reclaim” these experiences in their own lives,
Welton is encouraging Christians to pursue New Age witchcraft under the guise
of Christian spirituality.
For
example, Welton identifies “trances.” There are only two examples of
trances in scripture – when God prepared Peter to begin taking the gospel to
the Gentiles (Acts 10:9-10) and when God instructed Paul to flee Jerusalem for
safety (Acts 22:17-18). These were rare events initiated by God in the lives of
two men called as apostles—a highly
unusual calling.
Welton
identifies “having a spirit guide.” In the Bible, angelic visitations
are also rare and uninitiated encounters given to select individuals. For
example, angels broke apostles out of prison (Acts 5:19), guided Philip to an
Ethiopian eunuch who was ready to receive Christ (Acts 8:26), instructed
Cornelius to send for Peter who then brought the gospel to the Gentiles (Acts
10:3), broke Peter out of prison (Acts 12:7), and encouraged Paul that he would
not die (Acts 27:23).
However, The
Physics of Heaven promotes the witchcraft counterfeit of attempting to
conjure such experiences yourself. For example, Chapter 8 states:
“…the sound of angels can also be heard and
experienced by man. A whole new realm of encounter awaits those who possess…
expectancy, intentionality… Because…the angels are constantly interacting, we
can expect to hear them at times.”
“Intentionality as it applies to vibrational
sensitivity is simply the decision to see and to listen. No more passive seeing
or hearing. Activate your sensitivity to your aural and spiritual environment.
When you suspect a unique sound or light encounter—follow it.”
Welton
identifies “power objects.” Once again, God performing miracles through
an object is a very rare and uninitiated occurrence involving select
individuals, such as when God used Paul’s handkerchiefs or aprons to heal and
deliver people (Acts 19:11). By contrast, some New Age followers believe
certain objects such as crystals can have mystical, healing powers. And some
NAR leaders believe they have authority to declare objects anointed for healing
the way God did through Paul. For example, I recall during one MorningStar
conference session, Todd Bentley had attendees place various objects on the
stage. He then prayed a “declaration prayer” proclaiming that the objects would
transmit a healing anointing to the recipients for which they were intended.
Welton
identifies “auras,” which refer to emanating a spiritual presence. An
example from scripture might be when Moses’ face emanated God’s glory after
speaking to God face-to-face (2 Corinthians 3:13). The same points we have
already covered (God-initiated and rare versus voluntary conjuring and
accessible to everyone) apply once again.
Welton
identifies “clairvoyance, clairaudience,” which refer to seeing or
hearing spiritual things.
Clairvoyance
and clairaudience are arguably synonymous with hearing God’s voice, which we discussed
in Chapter 10.
Welton
identifies “meditation.” Biblical meditation is not even a supernatural
experience. It is setting one’s mind on God’s word, law, works, testimonies,
etc. For example, Psalm 1:2 says a righteous man “meditates day and night”
on God’s law. David says in Psalm 199:99, 148 that God’s “testimonies
are my meditation” and he will “meditate on Your word.” And
in Psalm 143:5, David says, “I meditate on all Your doings.”
By
contrast, New Age meditation is used as a gateway to a spiritual experience by
achieving altered states of consciousness using techniques such as sensory
deprivation, stillness of mind, inward concentration, mantra repetition, and/or
mental visualization. Thus, Welton’s encouragement to “reclaim” meditation as a
gateway to a spiritual experience is antibiblical and tantamount to witchcraft.
False Encouragement Not to Be Afraid of Deception
The
Physics of Heaven encourages readers not to be afraid of being
deceived as they study and reclaim precious New Age beliefs and practices. For
example, Davis offers herself as a model in Chapter 2, stating:
“…as we extract ‘precious’ truths… I refuse
to… fear that I will somehow be tainted or captured by the devil as I try to
recover and express those truths.”
Likewise, Welton
states in Chapter 5:
“Personally, I have a lot more faith in the
Lord’s ability to keep me than in the devil’s ability to steal me away.”
“If we are asking the Lord to restore the
authentic to us, why should we have so much fear of accidentally operating in
the counterfeit?”
Rick
Joyner used to say something similar. He would say that if you are afraid of
being deceived, it means you have more faith in the devil to deceive you than
you have in the Holy Spirit to guide you into all truth, quoting John 16:13.
This is a common teaching in the NAR.
My
ten-year journey recorded in Chapters 1-6 has shown me beyond all doubt that it
is possible for a true Christian who sincerely believes he is obeying the Lord
to become deeply deceived and entangled in demonic bondage when he is following
false teaching, false teachers, and counterfeit spiritual experiences.
And the assertion
in The Physics of Heaven that Christians can reclaim New Age techniques
to voluntarily conjure holy spiritual experiences is a false teaching by false
teachers that facilitate counterfeit spiritual experiences. Therefore, those
who follow the book should absolutely be afraid of deception. In fact, if they
persevere in it, I believe they are guaranteed deception.
We also
plainly see in scripture that sincere Christians can become deceived by false
teaching, false brethren, false teachers, false prophets, and false apostles. I
will not quote all of these passages verbatim, but examples include Matthew
7:15, 24:4-5, 11, 24, 2 Corinthians 11:3-4, 13-15, Galatians 4:8-11, 1 Timothy
4:1-2, and 2 Peter 2:1-3. This includes deceptive supernatural experiences that
cause sincere believers to drift away from Jesus Christ and begin worshipping
fallen angels, just as Paul warns in Colossians 2:18-19:
“Let no one keep defrauding you… by delighting
in… the worship of the angels, taking his stand on visions he has seen… not
holding fast to the head…”
Nevertheless,
Welton supports his position that Christians need not fear deception by citing Luke
11:11-13, which states:
“Which of you fathers, if your son asks for a
fish, will give him a snake instead? Or if he asks for an egg, will give him a
scorpion? If you then, though you are evil, know how to give good gifts to your
children, how much more will your Father in heaven give the Holy Spirit to
those who ask Him!”
Welton
then concludes:
“If we are asking for the Holy Spirit to do
something, we do not need to fear receiving a counterfeit.”
This generalization
is true enough when properly balanced with applicable caveats and qualifiers in
scripture. However, if we are studying and applying New Age techniques to
conjure spiritual experiences on our own initiative, in violation of scripture,
and then asking the Holy Spirit to protect and bless us, we should absolutely
fear receiving a counterfeit.
As we
bring this section to a close, I am reminded of a product I recently saw for
sale on Amazon.com called “The Holy Spirit Board.” It looks and works
exactly like a Ouija board, except the planchette is shaped like a cross and
the front cover of the box promises:
“Communicate Directly with Jesus Christ!”
The
product description states:
“The Holy Spirit Board is the only spirit
board designed to directly contact our lord and savior Jesus Christ! Unlike
other spirit boards that are often used to contact ghosts and demons, this is a
one-way ticket straight to heaven. Try it today, and discover a new way to
pray!”
“Perfect for churches, prayer groups or just
getting together with friends.”
“Unlike other spirit boards, this one will
NEVER contact evil ghosts or demons, so you can ask your questions with an
assured sense of safety.”
What a
perfectly logical extrapolation of the false teaching promoted in The
Physics of Heaven.
A New Kind of Faith, Minus God
In Chapter
12, Ellyn Davis identifies two New Age beliefs as sharing common ground with
biblical faith. One is “belief in the power of consciousness to influence
material reality.” The second is “belief that mankind is evolving to
higher levels of consciousness… where… we will consistently be able to alter
the nature of reality with our thoughts and intentions.”
If you are
wondering where on earth these ideas can be found in scripture, Davis quotes
Romans 4:17 as stating Christians can “call the things that are not as if
they are.” From this passage, she concludes:
“Christians believe that through faith (which
could be considered a form of ‘intent’) we can affect changes in the material
world…”
I remember
attending an evening service at MorningStar when Todd Bentley taught the same
concept, using the same verse. However, if someone were to read a handful of
additional words from Romans 4:17 that Davis and Bentley omitted, they would
find that the verse more fully reads:
“…God, who gives life to the dead and calls
into being that which does not exist.”
This verse
has nothing to do with Christians changing material reality with their faith!
The verse points out that God created the universe out of nothing. And,
while the overarching theme of Romans 4 is salvation by faith rather than
works, Paul’s purpose in highlighting God’s creative power in verse 17 is
merely to reinforce that our faith in Him is well-placed.
So, both
in Romans 4:17 and in her reimagined version of biblical faith, Davis replaces
God with human thoughts and intent. Perhaps this is fitting. So much of The
Physics of Heaven teaches Christians how to have spiritual experiences on
their own initiative, effectively bypassing God’s biblical role in such
experiences. What better addition than to define a new understanding of faith
that bypasses God as well?
How to Experience Heaven, Bethel-Style
The 2013
book, Experiencing the Heavenly Realm: Keys to Accessing Supernatural
Experiences, was primarily authored by Bill Johnson’s administrative
assistant Judy Franklin and co-authored by Bill Johnson’s wife and Bethel
senior pastor Beni Johnson. In the book’s forward, Bill Johnson states:
“These two authors are among the most
qualified people I know for such an endeavor to write a book about experiencing
God. One is my wife and the other is my secretary.”
“They are… introducing many of us to part of
our inheritance in Christ: an inheritance of encountering God and experiencing
realms of Heaven now.”
The back
cover advertises the following benefits for those who read the book:
“Activate your seeing capacity.”
“Experience love in the third heaven realm.”
Franklin
teaches that the key to conjuring heavenly experiences at will is to develop
one’s imagination. For example, she explains:
“You first have to realize that it’s
[experiencing heaven] not unlike seeing with our imaginations.” (pgs.
58-59)
“Everything you see [while experiencing
heaven], even if you feel like you are only imagining it, has significance.” (pg. 87)
She
credits Bob Jones for the term “sanctified imagination” and then quotes
Bill Johnson as stating:
“A sanctified imagination positions you for
dreams and visions.” (pgs. 58-59)
She leads
readers in the following prayer:
“…I ask for You to open my spiritual eyes…
Make my imagination a birthing place for Your visions, Your dreams, Your plan,
and Your purposes. Help my imagination… receive what You are speaking and
doing. In Jesus’ name, amen!” (pg. 64)
Every
year, the leadership of the Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry (BSSM) asks
Franklin at the beginning of the school year to “do [her] Heaven thing”
(pg. 175-176). She prepares the students by telling them that what they are
about to experience “looks like imagination, but it comes from one’s spirit,
and it is with the leading of the Holy Spirit.”
She tells
the students to close their eyes and keep them closed. She then tells them to
picture Jesus in front of them and waits for them to each raise a hand when
they see Him. She then tells them to walk up to Him until they are standing
right in front of Him. At this point, the book pauses to note:
“By this time His presence is growing very
strong because we have entered into a heavenly atmosphere…”
She then
tells the students Jesus is going to do something and waits for them to each
raise a hand when He does something. She then goes around with a microphone
while everyone’s eyes are still closed and asked the students to share what
Jesus did, such as a hug, a kiss, a touch, etc.
She then
tells the students He is going to say something and waits for them to each
raise a hand when He says something. She then goes around with a microphone
while everyone’s eyes are still closed and asked the students to share what
Jesus said, such as “I love you” or “I’m proud of you.”
Toward the
end of the book (pg. 213), Franklin invites the reader to begin experiencing
heaven in the same way, stating:
“…I want to help you personally experience the
heavenly realm… This [exercise] is specifically geared toward helping you
personally engage with Heaven in the same way that the Bethel students did.”
Of course,
some readers will rightfully become concerned that practicing overtly New Age
visualization/meditation techniques to manufacture heavenly experiences could
open the door to demonic influence. In response to such concerns, Franklin
deceptively assures readers that the only action Satan will take is to try to stop
Christians from using these techniques! She quotes Bill Johnson as stating the
following in response to these fears:
“Then your God is too small and your devil too
big.” (pg. 61)
And, for
her own part, Franklin asserts:
“…I’m no longer afraid of being deceived. Fear
comes from the enemy, and he doesn’t want us to experience God.” (pg. 61)
“…there is also a danger of missing out on
incredibly powerful and godly experiences because of the fear of being
deceived.” (pg. 59)
1.
The Physics of Heaven, 2015 (multiple authors)
2.
Judy Franklin and Beni Johnson, 2013, Experiencing
the Heavenly Realm: Keys to Accessing Supernatural Experiences