Content
from this article is duplicated in Chapter 24 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A
FALSE PROPHET.
The following caveat is included for liability reasons: The author
does not claim to have personal knowledge that any detail contained in this
article is true. Rather, the author merely asserts that every detail can be
found in one or more of the sources cited.
Sources for the Bethel’s involvement in the Shawn Bolz false prophecy
and sexual misconduct scandal include several Christian media outlets (CBN1,
Christian Post2,3,4, Christianity Today5, Crosswalk6,
Premier Christian7,8,9, Roys Report10,11,12), a few
non-Christian local/regional media outlets13,14,15, two public
statements by Bethel Church16,17, a Bethel Church Sunday morning
sermon18, and a 5-hour 50-minute investigative documentary by
Christian influencer Mike Winger19.
Bethel Promotes Shawn Bolz Globally
Shawn Bolz’s rise to global prominence in the prophetic movement
beginning in the early 2010s was largely due to Bethel’s influence. Bethel,
which is possibly the most famous charismatic church in the world, strongly
promoted and platformed Bolz. For over a decade, Bolz was frequently invited to
speak at Bethel and often joined Bethel leaders ministering at churches and conferences
around the world. Bethel pastor Kris Vallotton (second-in-command behind Bill
Johnson) stated in February 2026:
“We’re the
ones who put (Bolz) on a global platform.” 20
Bolz Becomes Famous for Words of Knowledge Later Revealed to Be Fraudulent
With Bethel’s endorsement, Bolz became known as one of the charismatic
movement’s most gifted and anointed prophets. He was invited to speak at
hundreds of large charismatic conferences across the world, he regularly
appeared on Christian television networks, and he became a prolific author.
Bolz especially became known for his apparent ability to supernaturally receive
and deliver highly precise words of knowledge from the stage. He would often
call out a person’s name, birthday, address, and other personal details,
despite never having met them. After sharing these details, Bolz would go on to
give that person a word of prophecy from God.
It was revealed that Bolz’s words of knowledge were actually prepared
beforehand by researching personal details of attendees that he data-mined from
social media. This pattern of ministry intensified after 2013, coinciding with
the widespread adoption of social media platforms.
Bethel Cuts Ties with Bolz After Sexual Abuse and Prophetic Fraud
Discovered
In 2019, a former member of Bolz’s ministry team spoke to Bethel
leaders about non-consensual, sexually explicit, and abusive behavior he
experienced from Bolz. Bethel leadership investigated the accusation by
speaking with three other former members of Bolz’s ministry team. The victims’
accounts corroborated one another across different time periods and locations.
The behavior spanned more than a decade. The behavior included getting naked in
front of younger male staff members or volunteers and performing sexual acts on
himself, often during ministry travel in hotel rooms or vehicles. Some of the
victims described long-term psychological harm, including suicidal thoughts and
symptoms consistent with post-traumatic stress disorder.
Also in 2019, shortly after Bethel began receiving sexual abuse
allegations, some respected European church leaders came to Bethel with 14
pieces of evidence that Bolz had been using personal details obtained from
social media to prepare fraudulent words of knowledge.
In response to all of this, Bethel leaders did the following:
1)
They confronted Bolz over several difficult
conversations.
2)
They met repeatedly with Bolz’s board, laid out all the
facts and evidence, and asked the board to pull Bolz out of ministry, which the
board chose not to do.
3)
They alerted other prominent charismatic ministry
leaders who had platformed Bolz.
4)
They suggested to some victims to seek remedy through
the legal system.
5)
They banned Bolz from any involvement with Bethel. He
was not permitted to minister at Bethel network locations or alongside Bethel
leaders/ministries, and all of his resources (books, teaching DVDs, etc.) were
removed from Bethel points of sale.
However, as we will see in a coming section, Bethel made no public
statement about Bolz’s sexual behavior or prophetic fraud until forced to do so
in February 2025 after texts between Bethel pastor Kris Vallotton and one of
Bolz’s sexual abuse victims were leaked on the internet.
More People Victimized by Bolz Due to Bethel’s Silence
As a result of Bethel’s decision not to make a statement in 2019 or
2020, more people were victimized by Bolz’s sexual abuse and fraudulent
prophetic ministry. In January 2026, Bethel’s lead pastor Bill Johnson
acknowledged:
“As a
result of my inaction… more people were affected, and additional injuries in
the prophetic and trauma in Shawn’s own team took place.” 21
In one well-known case, a woman named Jubilee Dawn served as an intern
at Bethel in the early to mid-2010s. While there, Bolz pretended to give her
words of knowledge using personal details she posted on social media. Bolz then
prophesied that God wanted her to marry her boyfriend at the time. After she
married him, Dawn discovered he was severely abusive to the point of nearly
taking her life, but she didn’t leave because Bolz’s prophecy convinced her God
wanted her to stay in the marriage. Dawn later blamed Bethel for its silence,
stating:
“It angered
me so much that Bethel never made an announcement—they never protected anyone from [Bolz].” 22
Kris Vallotton Cuts Off Victim Who Presses for Public Statement
In late 2020 and early 2021, one of Bolz’s sexual abuse victims texted
with Kris Vallotton after having shared his experience with Bolz. The victim
asked Vallotton why he was being dismissed like a nuisance and wondered when
Bolz would be held accountable for his actions. Vallotton replied that he
banned Bolz from Bethel involvement, but did not plan to take any further
steps.
The victim then asked if Bethel would be making a public statement to
warn all the people who had been introduced to Bolz through Bethel’s broad
influence. Vallotton replied that Bethel would not make a statement because to
do so would hurt the prophetic ministry worldwide. Since Bethel was perhaps the
world’s most famous prophetic ministry, this excuse was glaringly self-serving.
When the victim once again pressed Vallotton to warn the body of
Christ about Bolz, Vallotton told him to move on with his life, stop trying to
police Bethel’s actions, and stop trying to warn everyone about Bolz. Finally,
Vallotton instructed the victim not to contact him anymore.
After this text conversation was publicly leaked, Vallotton publicly
apologized in January 2026, stating:
“…regrettably,
when one of the victims of Shawn’s sexual allegations reached out to me for
help in this crisis, after several conversations and phone calls, I made a
decision to remove his access to me without compassion due to my personal
overwhelm. I am grieved by my actions.” 23
Bill Johnson Endorses Bolz’s Book Shortly After Meeting with Victim
Bill Johnson accepted an invitation in 2023 to be interviewed by TBN
to endorse Bolz’s newly released book on prayer. This was shortly after Johnson
had met with one of Bolz’s sexual abuse victims. Nevertheless, Johnson accepted
the invitation. Winger’s video showed the interview in which Johnson sat
directly beside Bolz and said:
“The book
by itself is incredible. Knowing the life that backs it up adds a power to it…”24
Bill Johnson later acknowledged that it was “absolutely foolish” and
“a horrible misjudgment.” In January 2026, Johnson stated:
“Doing the
TBN show, after learning of his damaging experience, and then promoting Shawn
and his book was a slap in the face to Shawn’s former team member, and to those
who suffered from Shawn’s behavior.” 25
Christian influencer Mike Winger called this endorsement an “atrocious
and evil” act. 26 As we will see in a coming section, Winger’s
investigative documentary was largely responsible for exposing both Bolz’s
abuse and Bethel’s concealment.
Kris Vallotton Deceitfully Claims He Is Unaware of Evidence Against Bolz
In January 2025, Bethel pastor Kris Vallotton engaged in a public
Instagram exchange after being asked by a man named Spencer Dalton why he was
not making any public statements after his text exchange with one of Bolz’s
sexual abuse victims was publicly leaked. Vallotton replied that “the crowd
demands to know every detail,” but it would be unwise to share the details
publicly, and people should trust him to deal with the situation properly in
private.
Dalton replied that the body of Christ justifiably wanted truth and
clarity and asserted that public sins should not be dealt with privately. In
response, Kris deceitfully implied he was not aware of any solid evidence that
Bolz had done anything wrong, stating:
“Do you
know for a fact Shawn did this? Are 100% sure he is guilty? Have seen the
evidence? Or are you listening to people on social media? As far as I know it’s
‘alleged’ and last I heard, Shawn hasn’t admitted to anything. Maybe more facts
have come out, I haven’t followed the situation for years.”
When another user asked why Bethel doesn’t make a statement defending
Bolz if Vallotton thinks the allegations are untrue, Vallotton seemed to switch
stance by implying that Bethel was not making a public statement because it
wanted to be in a position to restore Bolz if the allegations were true.
Vallotton stated:
“…I never
let the crowd tell me how to pastor people… if the accusations against Shawn
are true, there are many more like him… who have major issues who are leading.
Bethel has become a place for them to come and get well and whole. Most of them
remerge healthy, noble leaders.” 27
Bethel Statement Deceitfully Minimizes Bolz’s Sexual Abuse and Prophetic
Fraud Evidence
In early February 2025, less than a month after Kris Vallotton’s
Instagram exchange, Bethel released a public statement in response to the
preexisting online debate about Bolz’s ministry that had been further fueled by
Vallotton’s leaked texts and Instagram exchange.
This was the first of two public statements Bethel issued about Bolz.
The second came less than one year later, in January 2026, in response to Mike
Winger’s exposé.
Bethel began by heaping lavish praise on Bolz’s prophetic ministry and
the tremendous impact their partnership with Bolz had on Bethel over the years:
“Shawn Bolz
had ministered with us many times for many years, and had a great impact on our
house. We deeply valued and trusted him and appreciated his prophetic gift.
Many of us have received important, accurate prophecies, and words of knowledge
from him (prior to social media being so pervasive) that we had great
confidence in.” 28
Next, the statement addressed Bolz’s sexual abuse and prophetic fraud
allegations. A comparison between Bethel’s two public statements strongly
indicates that the first statement was a deceitful attempt at damage
control.
Regarding Bolz’s sexual behavior, the first statement only mentioned
two former staff members who were sexually abused and used vague, caveated
language. It said Bethel leaders were not “experts” in what technically
constituted sexual harassment, but the behavior described by the witnesses “seemed
to fit the descriptions of sexual harassment… commonly taught in HR training.”
It also claimed that Bolz acknowledged some past inappropriate behavior, but
the behavior had “stopped” and Bolz “responded [to Bethel’s
confrontation] by making some changes.” 29
By contrast, the second statement mentioned four former staff members
and left no doubt that Bolz “engaged in sexually explicit and harassing
behavior towards some members of his staff.” Further, it said Bolz “denied
the allegations,” and then “stopped engaging with us on the accusations
entirely.” Correspondingly, Kris Valotton privately texted in January 2021
that Bolz had “refused to clean up his mess.” 30
Regarding Bolz’s prophetic fraud, the first statement said Bethel
leaders were unable to reach a consensus regarding the evidence they received
because there was no “definitive proof.” Therefore, they said only Bolz
himself and the Lord “really know what took place.” 31
By contrast, the January 2026 statement left no room for doubt that
Bolz “was not truthful in how he received his words of knowledge.” 32
Bethel Statement Deceitfully Rationalizes Concealment of Bolz’s Sexual
Abuse and Prophetic Fraud
As we saw in a previous section, Bethel cut off all ministry ties with
Bolz in 2019 and asked his board to pull him out of ministry, but never
publicly revealed the allegations. Bethel’s February 2025 statement gave the
following four reasons for its silence:
1)
Bolz did not work directly for Bethel and was therefore
“not under our authority.”
2)
In the case of prophetic fraud, they didn’t have “team
consensus” or “definitive proof.”
3)
In the case of sexual abuse, they said it was the
victims’ “story to tell,” not theirs.
4)
In the case of sexual abuse, they said they thought
Bolz changed his behavior. 33
In addition to these four reasons, Kris Vallotton also told one of
Bolz’s sexual abuse victims in early 2021 that a public statement would “hurt…
the entire prophetic ministry worldwide.” 34
Bethel’s first reason for not going public—Bolz was not Bethel’s
authority—was both misleading and irrelevant. It was misleading because Bolz
was under the authority of Bethel worship leader Sean Feucht in 2019, according
to Bolz’s ministry’s IRS 990 form, which listed Feucht as a board member. It
was irrelevant because Bethel was not against publicly rebuking a leader who
did not work for them anyway, as Bethel’s February 2025 statement readily
acknowledged:
“In the
past, we have only brought public admonishment to those outside of our
organization in cases where no acknowledgment and change has taken place after
correction.” 35
Bethel’s second reason for not going public—not having definitive
proof—was effectively retracted in its second statement a year later, after
Mike Winger’s documentary showed the evidence was overwhelmingly definitive.
Bethel’s third reason for not going public—wanting to let the victims
tell their own stories—was profoundly deceitful insofar as multiple victims
asked Bethel to help them share their stories publicly to warn Bolz’s
followers, but Bethel refused. One victim did this over text, as we saw in a
previous section. Others eventually turned to Mike Winger for help, which he
provided via his documentary.
Bethel’s fourth reason for not going public—saying Bolz changed his
behavior—was effectively retracted in its second statement a year later.
Bethel’s fifth reason—wanting to protect the worldwide prophetic
ministry—was self-serving insofar as Bethel was possibly the most famous (and
profitable) prophetic ministry in the world. Plus, when Bethel’s cover-up of
Bolz’s actions eventually became known, it did far more damage to the global
prophetic ministry than if Bethel had been transparent about Bolz in the first
place.
Influencer Mike Winger Documents Bolz’s Abuse and Bethel’s Coverup
On January 17, 2026, Christian influencer Mike Winger posted to
YouTube a 5-hour 50-minute video entitled, “The Skeletons in Bethel’s Closet
are Now Going to Speak.” The video compiled months of research, victim
interviews, leaked texts, and documented evidence indicating that Shawn Bolz
had spent years both delivering fraudulent prophecies using personal details he
data-mined from the internet and practicing clergy sexual abuse against his own
ministry staff members. The video also documented that Bethel leaders knew of
these practices for years but kept them a secret. The video reached one million
views about one week after it had been posted.
Kris Vallotton Attacks Mike Winger
On Saturday, January 17, the day after Winger posted his video, Kris
Vallotton used Bethel’s Sunday morning sermon to respond. Although he never
mentioned the video or Winger or Bolz by name, his response was clearly a
scathing attack on both Winger’s motives and the video’s reliability. Here are
some of the key points of Vallotton’s message:
1)
He implied that the video was untrue.
2)
He implied that Winger’s motive in making the video was
financial gain.
3)
He likened the video to a form of blackmail in which
Winger essentially threatened Bethel with slander if they don’t share publicly
the things Winger wanted them to share.
4)
He implied that Bolz may be innocent and blamed social
media for creating an atmosphere in which people are presumed guilty unless
proven innocent.
5)
He claimed to have no reliable process for determining
someone’s guilt if that person denies wrongdoing, even if five witnesses say
otherwise.
6)
He implied that Winger was comparable to the Pharisees
who accused the woman caught in adultery and wanted to stone her.
7)
He implied that Winger’s motive in seeking to expose
Bolz and Bethel was self-righteousness and moral superiority.
8)
He implied that Winger was operating from a place of
fault-finding, judgement, and a lynch-mob mentality.
9)
He implied that publicly labeling Bolz as unsafe would
unjustly destroy his reputation.
10)
He implied that publicly labeling Bolz as unsafe would
unnecessarily lead non-believers away from the church and from Christ.
Former IHOP leader and Advocate Group member Jono Hall said Vallotton’s
message revealed that Bethel’s chief objectives when a prominent leader is
caught practicing predatory abuse are:
1)
Protect Bethel’s reputation
2)
Protect the prophetic movement’s reputation
3)
Protect the predatory leader’s reputation
In order to achieve these objections, Hall said that Bethel leadership
took these three actions:
1)
Remained silent about the accusations
2)
Claimed they were being persecuted for showing mercy to
the accused
3)
Refused to protect the sheep from further abuse
Jono Hall cited 1 Timothy 5:20 and other examples from scripture as
teaching that public, unrepentant sin required public exposure for the
protection of the church. Jono also noted that the deepest wounds experienced
by victims often are not due to the original abuse, but from so-called
shepherds who try to conceal the abuse when they learn of it because they care
more about protecting abusers and institutions than victims. 36
Bethel Issues Tearful Apology After Winger’s Video Goes Viral
One week later, on Sunday, January 25, 2026, three Bethel leaders—Dan
Farrelly, Kris Vallotton, and Bill Johnson—shared the pulpit to once again
respond to Mike Winger’s video. By this point, the video had accumulated over
one million views, and there was mounting criticism of Bethel both within the
global charismatic church and among Bethel’s 18,000 School of Ministry alumni
around the world. The language spoken from the pulpit closely paralleled the
language of the public statement released the same day.
Bethel called its handling of Bolz’s prophetic fraud and sexual abuse
a grievous mistake, a failure, and a sin. It credited Mike Winger’s video and
pressure from Bethel alumni with prompting them to finally repent. Vallotton
said his perspective had completely changed from one week prior and he finally
realized Bethel had a responsibility to warn the church of Bolz’s behavior.
Bill Johnson said his inaction caused more people to be victimized by Bolz.
Here are some quotes from the statement. The opening section
stated:
“We’re
writing to you today to share about some of our mistakes and failures in the
way we navigated our responsibilities to the global Body of Christ. We… seek
the Lord for forgiveness in the face of some grievous mistakes… We take
responsibility for the fact that we did not… bring… clear and timely
communication regarding the gravity of our concerns with Shawn Bolz.”
“…we are
responsible for our sins, actions, and inactions… we did not tell the truth
enough, early enough, long enough, or loud enough, and this is a just
criticism.”
“…our
alumni… there are 18,000 of them all over the earth… it was their communication
and agitation… that drew our attention… and subsequently other national voices,
to the necessity of… addressing this.”
Kris Vallotton’s section stated:
“…I have
had a change of perspective since my message last Sunday evening, and I’m
writing with a repentant heart today.”
“We should
have told our church and wider community in 2020. We did not. That was wrong.”
“We
platformed [Bolz] …and when he failed, and failed to repent, it was our
responsibility to tell people that we no longer trusted him in order to protect
them.”
“It grieves
me that someone would need to put out a video to prompt us to action. It’s an
indictment against my leadership.”
“During my
message on Sunday evening, January 18, I was in a different place… still not
realizing that we had placed Shawn on a global platform and the responsibility
we had in that.”
“As a
result of my conviction from the Lord and challenge from others, I came to
realize… [that] protecting people from those we platform is definitely our
responsibility.”
Bill Johnson’s section stated:
“As a
result of my inaction… more people were affected, and additional injuries in
the prophetic and trauma in Shawn’s own team took place.”
“…I did
this at the expense of the victims… It was incredibly careless… I contributed
to their trauma… I know that I failed.” 37
Bethel Denies Allegations of Deliberate Cover Up
Here is a concise timeline of Bethel’s actions:
·
In 2019 and 2020, Bethel banned Bolz from all
ministry association and asked Bolz’s board to remove him from ministry, but
didn’t reveal any of these actions or the allegations against Bolz to the body
of Christ.
·
In 2021, Kris Vallotton cut off communication
with one of Bolz’s sexual abuse victims who pressed him to make a public
statement.
·
In 2023, Bill Johnson gave a glowing endorsement
of Bolz’s book and ministry shortly after meeting with one of Bolz’s sexual
abuse victims.
·
In January 2025, Kris Vallotton deceitfully
implied over Instagram that he was not aware of any solid evidence that Bolz
had done anything wrong.
·
In February 2025, Bethel issued a deceitful
public statement that praised Bolz’s ministry, downplayed the seriousness of
his sexual abuse, and cast doubt on the evidence for his prophetic fraud.
·
In January 2026, Kris Vallotton leveled a
deceitful attack on Mike Winger’s motives and his video’s reliability.
·
One week later, after Winger’s video went viral,
Kris Vallotton and Bill Johnson issued tearful apologies for not publicly
exposing Bolz’s sins years earlier.
In light of these actions, Mike Winger asserted that Bethel had a “cover-up
culture” that seeks to conceal sin if public exposure could adversely
affect prominent Bethel-linked leaders or ministries. 38 Bill
Johnson dismissed this idea, telling his congregation during his apology
sermon:
“It’s
obviously not intentional. You don’t think through that stuff.” 39
1.
CBN, 1/26/2026, “Bethel Church Responds to Shawn
Bolz Sexual Misconduct Allegations and Fake Prophecy Scandal”
2.
Christian Post, 1/26/2026, “Bethel Church Admits
Failures After Mike Winger’s Shawn Bolz Exposé Reveals Prophetic Deception,
Sexual Abuse”
3.
Christian Post, 1/26/2027, “Shawn Bolz Scandal: An
Overdue Reckoning of the Charismatic Church”
4.
Christian Post, 2/4/2025, “Bethel Church Addresses
Allegations Shawn Bolz Used Social Media to Generate ‘Prophecies’”
5.
Christianity Today, 1/29/2026, “Shawn Bolz Scandal:
An Overdue Reckoning of the Charismatic Church”
6.
Crosswalk, 1/28/2026, “Bethel Leaders Admit Failures
in Response to Allegations against Shawn Bolz”
7.
Premier Christian, 1/26/2026, “Bethel Leadership
Breaks Silence as New Claims Emerge Over Shawn Bolz Misconduct”
8.
Premier Christian, 1/27/2026, “Bethel Church Admits
Cover-Up of Prophet Shawn Bolz Fraud and Abuse Allegations”
9.
Premier Christian, 2/7/2025, “Shawn Bolz: Bethel
Church Raises Concerns Over Alleged Fabricated Prophecies, Sexual Harassment”
10.
Roys Report, 1/22/2026, “Mike Winger Exposé Shows
Bethel Church’s ‘Extended Mercy’ Failed Victims,” by Jonathan “Jono”
11.
Roys Report, 1/26/2026, “Bethel Church Leaders
Apologize for Silence About Shawn Bolz’s Misconduct: ‘We Did Not Tell the Truth
Enough’”
12.
Roys Report, 2/5/2025, “Bethel Raises Concerns Shawn
Bolz Fabricated Prophecies Using Social Media”
13.
ABC 7 KRCR TV (Redding, CA), 1/26/2026, “Bethel
Leadership Apologizes for Allegations Against Guest Minister”
14.
Desert Sun, 1/27/2026, “Northern California
Megachurch Apologizes Over Misconduct of Star Pastor”
15.
Record Searchlight, 1/27/2026, “Bethel Responds to
Accusation It Hid Sexual Misconduct Allegations”
16.
Bethel, 1/25/2026, “An Important Letter from Bill,
Kris, and Dann on Behalf of Bethel Leadership”
17.
Bethel, 2/3/2025, “Bethel Statement on Shawn Bolz to
Alumni”
18.
Bethel, 1/17/2026, Bethel Church Sunday Morning Sermon
by Kris Vallotton, Redding, California
19.
Mike Winger, 1/17/2026, “The Skeletons in Bethel’s
Closet are Now Going to Speak.”
20.
Roys Report, 1/26/2026
21.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
22.
Premier Christianity, 1/27/2026
23.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
24.
Roys Report, 1/26/2026
25.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
26.
CBN, 1/26/2026
27.
Winger, 1/17/2026
28.
Bethel, 2/3/2025
29.
Ibid.
30.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
31.
Bethel, 2/3/2025
32.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
33.
Bethel, 2/3/2025
34.
Winger, 1/17/2026
35.
Bethel, 2/3/2025
36.
Roys Report, 1/22/2026
37.
Bethel, 1/25/2026
38.
Winger, 1/17/2026
39.
Roys Report, 1/26/2026