Content
from this article is duplicated in Chapter 26 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A
FALSE PROPHET.
The following caveat is included for liability reasons: The author
does not claim to have personal knowledge that any detail contained in this
article is true. Rather, the author merely asserts that every detail can be
found in one or more of the sources cited.
Sources for the Bethel’s involvement in the Jonathan Welton sexual
misconduct scandal include a couple of Christian media outlets (Charisma1,
Roys Report2), a Christian television show3, statements
by Bethel leader Danny Silk4,5, Jonathan Welton6,7, and a
Christian psychologist8, and a 6-hour exposé by Christian influencer
JonMark Baker 9.
Jonathan Welton Re-Launches Ministry After Moral Failure
In the 2000s, Jonathan Welton rose to prominence as an international
Christian speaker and author. He often partnered in ministry with Randy Clark,
central figure of the Toronto Blessing, since Welton worked at Clark’s ministry
(called Global Awakening) for a time and Clark wrote the foreword to Welton’s
2009 book The School of the Seers about prophetic revelation. However,
in 2010, Welton had an affair with a graduate of the Global Awakening ministry
school and he and Clark parted ways.
In 2012, Welton published a book entitled Eyes of Honor and
appeared on Sid Roth’s television show It’s Supernatural to promote it.
On the show, Welton said he struggled for ten years with sexual lust and a
pornography addiction, but then underwent a near-overnight Saul-to-Paul
transformation. He also relaunched into ministry that year, regularly speaking
at charismatic churches and conferences.
Welton Founds Bible School, Sexually Grooms and Abuses Female Staff
In 2013, Welton founded Welton Academy (originally named Supernatural
Bible School), a ministry school dedicated to helping students grow in
supernatural ministry. Over the next few years, the academy grew into a
multinational online teaching ministry with 11 staff members who worked
remotely across a half-dozen U.S. states and two foreign countries. They
frequently joined Welton on monthly ministry trips and biannual staff retreats
in upstate New York.
Welton recruited mostly young female staff members from among the
academy’s student body by choosing women who matched his preferred appearance
and personality type. He then positioned himself as their spiritual father
seeking to empower them to discover their God-given identities and callings.
Finally, he gradually and methodically subjected them to sexual grooming,
harassment, and abuse.
The earliest accounts of sexual grooming/harassment/abuse of staff
members began in 2014, and the number of victims grew to more than a dozen by
the academy’s closure in 2018. Here are some examples of Welton’s behavior:
·
Welton told Chief Operations Officer Renee Bosco
over text that she could repay a debt to him by giving him blowjobs.
·
Welton Academy Mission Director Dawn Weaver said
Welton often initiated lengthy hugs, back rubs, and hand-holding.
·
A female staff member who asked to remain
anonymous said Welton forcibly groped and kissed her during a ministry trip.
·
Welton set up a private Facebook group for some
of the female staff members and then asked them to send him a selfie every day
for 21 days. He also used the Facebook group to share sexually suggestive
memes.
·
Welton sent inappropriate texts to numerous
female staff members and then asked them to delete them.
Staff members who refused to accept Welton’s physical affections were
terminated. When Eric Gregson, one of Welton Academy’s board members, first
confronted Welton about his inappropriate physical affection, Welton claimed
that God had done such a transformative work in his life when he was delivered
from his pornography addiction that he couldn’t help but see the women like his
own daughters, and this is what drove his affection toward them.
On his website, Welton later stated:
“[I know]
how deeply inappropriate I was in my communication with my staff… I was deeply
manipulative and completely dangerous to be in leadership… I also know that my
behavior was terrible and I deeply hurt some people I really care about.”10
Per the Roys Report (7/6/2023), Welton also stated:
“I
manipulated and used others as my narcissistic supply through unwanted physical
advances… I said countless horrible things… [and] hurt and destroyed the hearts
of wonderful people…”11
A member of Welton’s Accountability Board (formed after Welton Academy
closed) and clinical psychologist Dr. Ron Young stated (3/22/2020):
“Jon has
done a masterful job, up to now, surrounding himself with people he believes he
can manipulate or attempt to control… Jon’s actions towards women were not poor
boundaries that led to mistakes, but they were calculated and intentional.” 12
Bethel’s Danny Silk Unsuccessfully Attempts to Dismiss or Cover Up Welton’s
Abuse
The first victims of Welton’s sexual abuse began coming forward in the
summer of 2017. In October, some of the staff members, including COO Renee
Bosco, confronted Welton over his behavior. Welton acted tearfully repentant
and agreed to confess his behavior to his wife and the academy’s supervisory
board. However, in March 2018, the staff members who confronted Welton learned
that he had not followed through, so they turned for help to board member Eric
Gregson, who began actively working to ensure all staff and board members were
aware of Welton’s behavior. As awareness spread, Welton abruptly dissolved the
board in August 2018 in an attempt to cover up his actions.
In late August, former members of the now-dissolved board reached out
to Bethel Pastor Danny Silk since Bethel had partnered with Welton and endorsed
his ministry over the years. Silk’s desire to dismiss or cover up Welton’s
actions and quickly return him to ministry was immediately apparent. When Eric
Gregson spoke on the phone with Silk for the first time, the first thing Silk
said was:
“Why do you want to hurt Jonathan Welton?”
Gregson was “shocked” by this opening question, and explained
the rest of the conversation this way:
“[Danny
Silk] hadn’t spoken to any of the women… he’d only spoken to Jon, and he
clearly believed Jon’s perspective and was not interested in getting another
perspective at the time… I went on to explain… all the evidence… [of] what had
happened with a lot of the women, and Danny wasn’t buying it… He just saw it
as… Jon had made a couple of inappropriate jokes [and] there had been a few
missteps…”
“Danny had
been fully convinced that… I was overexaggerating. The women were
overexaggerating. It was… inappropriate touching, but it was just affection… it
was very downplayed. He had fully bought into Jonathan Welton’s story and… had
very little interest in hearing anyone else’s perspective [including] the women
that were affected.” 13
Silk was quickly forced to abandon his position. A couple of days
after the phone conversation, the female staff member who Welton forcibly
groped and kissed received an anonymous e-mail threatening her if she did not
delete all her text messages from Welton, saying:
“If he goes
down, you’re going down with him.” 14
Eric Gregson, who had a background in web development, pulled the IP
address off the e-mail and matched it to Welton’s IP address. When Gregson
confronted Danny Silk with this latest development, Silk did an obligatory
one-eighty and wrote the following in a letter addressed to all Welton Academy
personnel on September 18, 2018, despite still having never actually spoken to
any of the victims:
“Jon’s
behavior is beyond hurtful and scary; he is now toxic to those who choose to be
connected to him. A web of lies, created in a world that Jon controlled, is now
revealing numerous victims of his extremely selfish, humiliating, and habitual
behavior.”
“Regular
occurrences of physical advances, sexual innuendoes, and highly inappropriate
conversations became the culture Jonathan created around himself. The staff,
almost entirely younger women, were subject to this confusion and dishonor
while attempting to help something and someone they held in high esteem.”
“Repentance
is not clear, and thus the warning you hear in this letter. No repentance, no
change. That reality creates an ongoing expectation of more of the same. Jon is
not fit to be a leader, nor is he safe to have access to other people’s
vulnerability.”
“He is not
yet able to convince anyone around him that he’s broken over what he’s done to
so many and has absolutely no credibility when he speaks… Up to now, he has
spun all of his responsibility outward.” 15
Welton is Diagnosed as a Worst-Case Narcissistic Sociopath; Silk Tries to
Keep Diagnosis Secret
Danny Silk’s letter also detailed the terms of a proposed
accountability process moving forward, including:
·
Welton Academy would be closed immediately and
indefinitely.
·
Jon Welton would have no contact with former
staff members.
·
Welton Academy would compensate former staff
members in need of professional counseling.
·
Jon Welton would not be permitted to minister or
write books until further notice.
·
Jon Welton would seek psychological help and
follow the counsel of the selected psychologist.
In addition to Danny Silk, the process was overseen by an
accountability board with seven members, including Eric Gregson (former Welton
Academy board member), Steve Hogan (lead pastor of the local church Welton
attended in Rochester, New York), and Dr. Ron Young (Christian clinical
psychologist).
Early in the process, Welton was required to undergo a full
psychological evaluation by a third-party psychologist (not Accountability
Board member Dr. Ron Young). The psychologist diagnosed him as being both a
narcissist and a sociopath (formally known as narcissistic personality disorder
and antisocial personality disorder). She specified that Welton was the worst
case she had encountered in her 30 years of practice. Accountability Board
member Dr. Ron Young later corroborated this assessment. However, Danny Silk
tried to discourage the board from revealing this diagnosis to the public.
Four characteristics of sociopaths are16,17,18,19:
·
Charm: They are extremely charismatic and
charming.
·
Unscrupulousness: They have little to no
regard for the rights or feelings of others and therefore lack any remorse for
hurting others.
·
Dishonesty: They are extremely skilled
liars, able to fabricate a version of events that deflects blame and escapes
accountability.
·
Manipulation/control: They have a talent
for understanding people, picking up on the subtle cues, and manipulating them
for their own benefit. They love the feeling of having control over others.
According to Gregson, as the accountability process unfolded over the
next 2-3 years, at no point did Welton admit to any wrongdoing on his own.
Rather, the reoccurring pattern was that the board would introduce evidence of
an abusive action, Welton would initially deny it, then as the evidence became
overwhelming and undeniable, Welton would finally concede but minimize its
seriousness. Thus, zero progress was made throughout the entire process in
terms of Welton fully and voluntarily taking responsibility for specific
abusive actions.
Silk Quickly Pushes for Welton’s Restoration into Ministry Despite No
Change/Repentance
Danny Silk consistently pushed the idea that if Jon and Karen’s
marriage is reconciled, this means Welton is healthy and ready to be restored
into ministry. In the spring of 2019, mere months after the closure of Welton
Academy and Welton’s diagnosis as a narcissistic sociopath, Danny Silk hosted a
meeting where he presented Welton to the accountability board as “fully
repentant.” During the meeting, Welton spent several minutes weeping as he
shared how sorry he was for hurting Karen and explained how much better their
marriage was now. Confused, Eric Gregson responded that he was glad the
marriage had improved, but this had nothing to do with why Welton was pulled
out of ministry in the first place. He then asked:
“Can you
tell us why you used your power and position and the word of God to manipulate
women into sexual encounter?”
Neither Welton nor Danny Silk had any answer for this question. Silk
later described Welton’s response to Gregson’s question this way:
“I watched
Jonathan start to freeze up and get defensive as he struggled to answer. His
fear reaction continued through the rest of the conversation, which did not end
well, and for several weeks after that, I heard only radio silence from
Jonathan.”
Welton claimed he reacted this way because of a “fear dynamic he
had always had in his relationship” with Gregson—an explanation that Silk
readily accepted. Gregson rejected this explanation, saying:
“[Jon] wasn’t
afraid of the relational dynamic. He was afraid because his tactic didn’t work.
He thought he can get on a call and cry alligator tears about him and his wife
and that we’d all let him off the hook without ever owning any of the stuff
that he did.” 20
Silk Insists Victims Face Welton Alone
According to Welton’s local church pastor Steve Hogan, throughout the
process, Danny Silk was far more concerned with restoring the abuser than
helping the victims. For example, according to Eric Gregson, when it came time
for victims to be given the opportunity to confront Welton if they wished,
Danny Silk insisted “they had to confront him by themselves, which for the
majority of the board… was highly problematic.” Gregson explained:
“What we’re
doing is putting them in a position where they now have to face someone that we
know and has been verified by two clinicians… is an expert in psychological
manipulation. And now we’re going to take this girl and put her in a scenario
by herself where she has to address this guy. It was just horrifying to hear
that was the position he wanted to put these women in… [but] Danny Silk would
not approve of a scenario the where the women could talk with him with someone
else present.” 21
Welton Mocks Abuse Victims and Sows Division in Local Church
As part of the process, Welton was required to regularly attend his
local home church in Rochester, New York, led by accountability board member
Steve Hogan. Welton was not allowed to exercise any form of ministry or
leadership in the church. However, Welton secretly started a home group with
several men from the church and required each of them to sign a confidentiality
agreement. During the meetings, Welton mocked his abuse victims and gradually
turned some of the group members against church leadership. When some of the
group members broke their confidentiality agreement and informed Steve Hogan,
Hogan was forced to kick Welton out of the church in April 2020, citing his “past
and ongoing lying, manipulation, triangulation and covert divisive behavior.”
22
Silk Publishes Book Deceitfully Claiming Welton Improving and Will Soon
Return to Ministry
In October 2019, about one year after the collapse of Welton Academy,
Danny Silk published his book Unpunishable: Ending Our Love Affair with
Punishment, with a central theme of restoring fallen leaders into ministry.
The last three chapters were devoted to discussing Welton’s accountability
process. Silk claimed that Welton was “halfway to recovery” and implied
that he would soon be restored to ministry. 23 Silk continued
pushing the idea that a healthy marriage equals readiness for ministry,
writing:
“Karen
echoed her husband… that [restoration] begins with our family… see[ing] our
connection with each other and our kids grow strong and healthy. If we can
build… our love and honor for each other, then any ministry God opens for us
will be an overflow of that. When I heard these responses, I thought, they’re
on their way… I am confident that if they continue along this path of
connection, we will see them back in ministry.” 24
However, Welton’s victims and some of the accountability board members
were shocked by the book, asserting that it was deceptive and dangerous. Welton
Academy Executive Director Linsey Wallace said:
“…there was
no… factchecking. There was no permission asked to share any of the stories
that were in there… It was all Jonathan’s perspective, Jonathan’s narrative of
the stories and things that had happened. So, it was very minimized. It was
watered down and… dismissive of… what actually had happened to the staff.” 25
The book compelled victims Welton Academy Mission Director Dawn Weaver
and COO Renee Bosco to go public with their stories on a blog. Dawn Weaver
said:
“The voice
of any of Jon’s victims is completely absent from the book.” 26
Steve Hogan said the truth of what was happening in Welton’s
accountability process was “very counter to the picture that Danny is
painting in the book.” Hogan also noted the obvious conflict of interest
Silk created by publishing the book, saying:
“Danny was
running in the direction that he wanted to, and obviously… he had a book out
there. This needed to come to a good conclusion.” 27
Steve Gregson said he was “shocked” by the book and described
its message about restoring abusive leaders as “demonic” and “full of
lies,” stating:
“…the book
is not honest. There’s a level of dishonesty in there… That ideology that has
gone out over the charismatic movement [from] Bethel [to] people like me who
were looking up to those guys… People who are looking at John and thinking
that… Danny Silk’s word is a stamp of approval of John’s restoration. That is
frightening… and it’s demonic… It moves people towards manipulation and
destruction… If that’s what the book is endorsing, it’s wrong. It’s full of
lies.” 28
Even Jonathan Welton later acknowledged on his website:
“The
concern was that I hadn’t really changed and this book was going to launch an
unchanged Jonathan back in ministry (a very valid fear at the time).” 29
Silk Again Claims Welton Improving Despite Ongoing Manipulation
In early 2020, the accountability board learned that Welton was
violating the accountability process by writing a book and sending it around to
people for feedback. They also learned that Welton had been calling and texting
certain individuals to learn which members of the board he could manipulate. In
March 2020, accountability board member and clinical psychologist Dr. Ron Young
wrote a letter to all victims and leaders involved in the process, warning that
Welton was continuing “familiar manipulative and self-serving actions”
and was “still a great risk” to “groom and manipulate women.”
Therefore, there was “no plan to restore Jonathan to any type of ministry at
this present time.” Without mentioning Danny Silk specifically, Dr. Young
added that Welton was presently “surrounding himself with people he believes
he can manipulate.” 30
The following month, as we saw previously, Welton’s local church
pastor, Steve Hogan kicked Welton out of his church, citing his “past and
ongoing lying, manipulation, triangulation and covert divisive behavior.”
31 At that same time, according to Welton Academy Missions Director Dawn
Weaver, Danny Silk was “making videos… and releasing letters saying how well
Jon is doing.” 32
Silk Unilaterally Disbands Accountability Board and Declares Welton
Restored
In early 2021, two accountability board members resigned due to Danny
Silk refusing to listen to Dr. Ron Young’s advice concerning Welton’s ongoing
manipulation. In May 2021, Dr. Young himself likewise resigned from the board
because he learned that Danny Silk was planning to shortly declare Welton fully
repentant/transformed despite Dr. Young asserting that Welton “had not
changed.” 33 (Unlike Danny Silk, who never reached out to any of
Welton’s victims, Dr. Young donated hundreds of hours to helping them recover
from their experiences.)
One month later, in June 2021, Danny Silk unilaterally disbanded the
accountability board and released a public letter claiming Welton was “transformed”
and he was thus removing all constraints on his future ministry endeavors. Silk
said Welton did not plan to re-launch a public ministry at that moment, but
also made it clear he was free to do so whenever he chose. The letter stated:
“I’ve
watched a transformation in [Jonathon and Karen Welton] individually and as a
married couple… The board of advisors that Jonathon agreed to submit himself to
is dissolved… The limitations that were implemented in the beginning of this
process are no longer in place… [although] Jonathon has no plans to re-enter
any positions of ministry at this point… I expect that this will be my last
update on this matter. Jonathon will now face the public as a man who is indeed
living out the ‘Better Covenant’ message.” 34
Looking back on Silk’s reckless choice, Steve Hogan recalled:
“…there was
some discussion on the advisory board of… say[ing] ‘Listen, we cannot allow
this guy to be out there ministering again. This is the chance to… protect the
body of Christ,’ and Danny wasn’t willing to do it. Everybody else on the
advisory board… had grave concerns about Jonathan ever being in any type of
ministry role again or having access to people’s vulnerabilities.” 35
Welton Returns to Ministry; Podcast Accuses Silk of Coverup
Over the next two years, Welton returned to podcasting and men’s
coaching, published a biblical commentary, published a new book entitled The
Bulletproof Husband, and made his Welton Academy teaching videos publicly
available. Welton claimed to have apologized to his victims, but several of
them countered that he never apologized for anything “specific.” Welton
Academy Mission Director Dawn Weaver explained:
“When he is
supposedly apologizing, Jonathan doesn’t mention any of the things that he’s
sorry for or the things of which he’s taking ownership. It just comes across as
very hollow and self-serving.” 36
JonMark Baker, host of the “Minor Prophets” podcast, posted a
six-hour exposé of Welton and Silk on May 18, 2026, that featured extensive
interviews of Eric Gregson, Steve Hogan, and five of Welton’s abuse victims
(including Renee Bosco, Dawn Weaver, and Linsey Wallace). JonMark opened the
podcast by describing Unpunishable and the restoration process it
promotes this way:
“What you
are about to see… is the very epicenter of coverup culture in the charismatic
movement. We’re about to expose… a corrupt process that has formed the
foundation of a book called Unpunishable
that has proliferated coverup culture across the charismatic movement…”37
1.
Charisma, 6/15/2021, “Former Ministry Leader
Jonathan Welton Shares Letter from Mentor Danny Silk Verifying His Active
Healing Process”
2.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023, “Disgraced Teacher Jonathan
Welton Stages Ministry Comeback Over Victims’ Objections”
3.
It’s Supernatural! With Sid Roth, 5/7/2012, “Jonathan
Welton – Honor”
4.
Danny Silk, 9/18/2018, Letter to Welton Academy
5.
Danny Silk, 6/10/2021, Letter of Release of Jonathan
Welton
6.
Jonathan Welton’s Website (https://jonwelton.com/),
accessed 2026, “My Journey”
7.
Jonathan Welton’s Website (https://jonwelton.com/),
accessed 2026, “Roys Report”
8.
Dr. Ron Young, 3/22/2020, Letter to former Welton
Academy students and Jonathan Welton associates
9.
Minor Prophets Podcast with JonMark Baker, 5/18/2026, “Bethel’s
Book Platformed a Wolf and Silenced His Victims”
10.
Welton’s Website, 2026 (accessed), “My Journey”
11.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023
12.
Dr. Ron Young, 3/22/2020
13.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
14.
Ibid.
15.
Danny Silk, 9/18/2018
16.
Healthline, 12/18/2024, “What Is a High-Functioning
Sociopath?”
17.
Medium, 7/4/2018, “Five Ways to Spot a Sociopath”
18.
Pacific Beach Health, accessed 2026, “Pathological
Liar vs Sociopathic Liar”
19.
WebMD, 10/14/2025, “Sociopaths: Warning Signs and
Red Flags”
20.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
21.
Ibid.
22.
Ibid.
23.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023
24.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
25.
Ibid.
26.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023
27.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
28.
Ibid.
29.
Welton’s Website, 2026 (accessed), “My Journey”
30.
Dr. Ron Young, 3/22/2020
31.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
32.
Ibid.
33.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023
34.
Danny Silk, 6/10/2021
35.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026
36.
Roys Report, 7/6/2023
37.
Minor Prophets, 5/18/2026