Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 12 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
The
Toronto Blessing was a highly influential supposed Christian revival that began
in 1994 at Toronto Airport Christian Fellowship (TACF). TACF leaders John and
Carol Arnott publicly credited a spiritual impartation they received from Benny
Hinn with starting the Toronto Blessing.1,2 Both the Toronto
Blessing and Benny Hinn profoundly impacted the three ministries I followed
during my years in the New Apostolic Reformation—MorningStar,
IHOP, and Bethel.
According
to Mike Bickle of IHOP, spiritual impartations from both Benny Hinn and the
Toronto Blessing were at the root of IHOP’s conception. Bickle said a spiritual
anointing led him to first prophesy of IHOP’s founding while he was onstage
with Hinn at a Toronto conference in 1996. Later that same day, at TACF, Bickle
said the main prophet of the Toronto Blessing confirmed that God was calling
him to start IHOP. Bickle also publicly endorsed the Toronto Blessing and said
its attendees were criticized by other Christians because of their openness to
the Holy Spirit.3
Bill
Johnson of Bethel credited his ministry’s global influence to an impartation he
received at the Toronto Blessing.4 Bethel publicly associated itself
with both Benny Hinn and TACF since at least 2010.5 Bethel hosted a
Benny Hinn service in 2017.6
Rick
Joyner of MorningStar praised the Toronto Blessing as a significant move of God
that impacted his ministry and credited it to the Arnotts’ hunger for a
spiritual impartation and desire to impart it to others.7
Benny Hinn’s
foundational influence on the Toronto Blessing and prominent NAR ministries warrants
a closer look at his ministry.
In October
of 2018, Benny Hinn’s nephew Costi Hinn shared his testimony at Redeemer Bible
Church in Gilbert, Arizona at a conference entitled, “Another Gospel? A
Biblical Call to Discernment.” It was a remarkable account. After
graduating high school in the late 1990s or early 2000s, Costi joined Benny’s
entourage for a year and a half. The “self-appointed” (Costi’s words)
apostles and prophets that surrounded Hinn repeatedly prophesied that Costi
would eventually replace Benny as the heir to his Word of Faith empire and take
it to “greater heights.”
Costi
traveled the world and helped stage Hinn’s crusades. Costi described in detail
the breathtaking extravagance that Hinn and his entourage habitually enjoyed as
they stayed at resorts frequented by the rich and famous. Costi later asserted
that Hinn was a false prophet preying on the sick and hurting to enrich
himself.
Costi
recalled that members of Hinn’s ministry were forbidden from questioning or
challenging Hinn. Interestingly, when Hinn and others laid hands on Costi’s
future wife for spiritual impartation, causing her to be slain in the spirit, she
said it was the darkest and most demonic experience of her life. Costi believes
Hinn imparted a demonic anointing.8
In the
late 1990s and 2000s, Hinn was the world’s most successful faith healer,
typically conducting twenty-four free 2-day crusades per year that averaged
50,000 to 60,000 people in attendance. Hinn’s TV show was one of the
most-watched Christian TV programs in the world, with viewers in 190 countries.9
Hinn’s ministry brought in $100 to $200 million per year and was not a member
of the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA).10,11
Hinn taught followers that if they supported his ministry, God would give them
back more in return.12,13 An independent investigation corroborated
Costi’s narrative of opulent extravagance.14 Hinn would not publicly
disclose how his ministry handled money.15
Hinn
asserted that his ministry exhaustively investigated and medically
substantiated all miraculous healing claims that were broadcast on his TV show.16,17,18
However, in one televised crusade in Portland, 76 miracles were claimed
onstage. Hinn’s ministry eventually provided documentarians with contact
information for five, none of whom had been healed.19 At another televised
crusade in Las Vegas, 56 miracles were claimed. Hinn’s ministry would not provide
documentarians any evidence from that crusade, but instead provided contact
information for five other healing claimants. None of the claimants were able
or willing to provide medical evidence of healing.20 At another televised
crusade in Toronto, dozens of miracles were claimed, which Hinn subsequently
said were medically verified on his TV show. Despite Hinn’s stonewalling,
documentarians were able to find four of the healing claimants, none of whom
turned out to have been healed.21 Costi said he never saw a
legitimate healing when he was a part of his uncle’s entourage, only deception.22
Hinn
asserted someone could be legitimately healed at his crusades only to have the
illness or injury return later because they doubted God.23,24
One
miraculous healing was medically documented. A Hinn critic asserted that some
legitimate healings likely do take place despite Hinn’s fraud due to thousands
of Christians praying together.25
Hinn crusades
reserve a section in the back away from the stage for the disabled and those in
wheelchairs. Hinn crusades employ a screening system run by persons with no
medical expertise to visually verify that someone is able-bodied before he or
she is permitted onstage with Hinn.26,27
Some
documentarians, medical professionals, and other observers asserted that many
healing claims in Hinn’s crusades were psychosomatic and were attributable to
factors such as crowd size, audiovisual stimulation, duration, lateness, and
heightened anticipation.28,29,30
1.
John Arnott, 10/19/1994, Toronto Airport Christian
Fellowship (message transcript)
2.
Sid Roth, 11/16/2017, “It’s Supernatural,”
Interview with John and Carol Arnott
3.
Mike Bickle, 2002, “Encountering Jesus,” Session
11
4.
Bill Johnson, 5/2011, “Catch the Fire Toronto”
(interview transcript)
5.
Record Searchlight, 1/19/2010, “Bethel Lists
Evangelical Ministries as Its Friends”
6.
Bill Johnson, 1/16/2017, public Facebook post
7.
Rick Joyner, 6/6/2005, “Word of the Week: Creating a
Clean Heart – Part 15”
8.
Costi Hinn, 10/2018, “Another Gospel? A Biblical
Call to Discernment” (message given at Redeemer Bible Church in Gilbert,
Arizona)
9.
Los Angeles Times, 7/27/2003, “The Price of Healing”
10.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002, “Benny Hinn Has Millions
of Believers and Millions In Donations” (transcript)
11.
The Fifth Estate (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation),
12/2004, “Do You Believe in Miracles?”
12.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
13.
The Fifth Estate (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation),
1/12/2020, “The Insider: Tales from Inside Benny Hinn Ministries”
14.
Ibid.
15.
Los Angeles Times, 7/27/2003
16.
Ibid.
17.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
18.
The Fifth Estate, 12/2004
19.
HBO, 2001, “A Question of Miracles”
20.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
21.
The Fifth Estate, 12/2004
22.
The Fifth Estate, 1/12/2020
23.
Christianity Today, 9/20/2017, “Benny Hinn Is My
Uncle, but Prosperity Preaching Isn’t for Me”
24.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
25.
Los Angeles Times, 7/27/2003
26.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
27.
The Fifth Estate, 12/2004
28.
HBO, 2001
29.
NBC Dateline, 12/27/2002
30.
The Fifth Estate, 12/2004