The Bible contains many
seeming contradictions. In fact, many of the most basic doctrines are debated
by scholars precisely because several passages can reasonably be used to
support opposing views. At times, it can almost seem like God intentionally made
His word confusing and inconsistent. However, I believe God set multiple truths
in tension with one another so that we would carefully search out scripture’s
counsel on a topic to find a balance that properly esteems everything He
canonized.
Exodus
33:20, John 1:18, 6:46, and 1 John 4:12 all state unequivocally that no one has
ever or can ever see God. Yet Revelation 1, 4, Daniel 7, Ezekiel
1, and Isaiah 6 all depict certain men doing exactly that, not to mention
Genesis 18:1-2, Exodus 33:11, Joshua 5:14, and Acts 23:11. Did one set of
passages get it wrong? Perhaps the answer is that our frail, fallen human
frames cannot endure being in the full manifest presence of the Father face to
face, but this does not apply to seeing God in a vision or when He takes on a
human form.
In Matthew 12:30, Jesus
said, “He
who is not with Me is against Me”. Yet in Mark 9:40, He said the opposite:
“For he who is not against us is for us.”
Why the contradiction? Perhaps these are principles that each apply to some
situations, but not all situations. (In the first passage, Jesus was speaking
to the Pharisees while they opposed ministry. In the second, He appears to be
speaking about a sincere
believer who cast out a demon using Jesus’ name, but did not follow along with
the disciples.)
These are minor examples
compared to others we could examine. For example:
·
Does God know the future? Can He change His mind, be surprised, or not yet know
what someone will choose?
·
Who has authority over the earth? Does God? Does Satan? Does man?
Who determines which kings or rulers will take power?
·
Does God’s sovereignty override human free will? If we can be held
responsible for evil choices, can we not also be responsible for righteous
ones?
·
Are
we saved solely because of God’s pursuit or do we have to respond? Can believers become lost
again after being saved?
·
Does God already know who will be saved and who will remain lost?
Does He actively predetermine who
will be saved and who will remain lost?
Approach for Resolving
Contradictions
How do we reconcile seemingly contradicting sets of passages? I
propose an approach that asks three sequential questions. I believe asking
these questions in this order is the best way to honor scripture. The questions
are:
1)
Is
there any sense or context in which both sets of passages could be true at the
same time without any contraction?
2)
Could
both sets of passages be true at the same time despite contradicting because it is beyond our limited human
capacity to grasp how they can both be true?
3)
Is
one set of passages meant to be taken at face value while the other is meant to
be taken figuratively?
The
order is significant. The assumption behind them is that, unless scripture
itself states or clearly implies otherwise, God spoke plainly. He meant what He
said and He said what He meant. When balancing passages are held in proper
tension with one another, the answers can be quite nuanced. After all, God, Satan, angels, demons, man, creation, time, salvation, and
free will all interact with and affect one another, sometimes in complicated
ways.
I believe some common doctrines are erroneous because believers
have been taught to assume certain passages must be figurative if they violate
philosophical, unbiblical presuppositions about God, Satan, angels, demons,
man, creation, time, salvation, or free will. However, if we begin by assuming
that God spoke plainly and ask whether seemingly contradictory passages could
be true simultaneously, they usually can.
One
key sentence is often
the key to properly interpreting the whole counsel of scripture on a disputed
topic:
Omission
is not denial.
For example, one set of passages might emphasize
God’s sovereignty in the lives of nations or individuals and omit the free will
of men. A second set does the opposite – emphasizes the free will of man and
omits God’s sovereignty. At this point, some Bible teachers then mistakenly
think the two sets contradict each other and, therefore, one set must be
figurative.
In reality, the two sets don’t contradict at all
because… Omission is not denial. Both sets can be taken at face without any
contradiction as long as their applications are properly nuanced or caveated.
While
most major doctrinal disputes can be resolved without moving past question one,
some require moving to question two. One example, in my opinion, would be the
Trinity. Is there one God or are the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit each God? I
believe the answer is yes to both. There is one God that also somehow embodies
relationship and selfless love between the three members of the Trinity. It is
simply beyond our limited human capacity to fully grasp. This is what’s known as an antimony—two apparently
contradicting truths.
I
believe most major doctrinal disputes do not require moving to question three.
However, an obvious exception is in the area of prophecy/eschatology. It is the
nature of prophecy to contain heavy symbolism, which is meant to be taken
figuratively by definition. Thankfully, the meanings of most if not all
biblical symbols are identified in scripture. Nevertheless, there are still
many different interpretations of prophetic/eschatological passages among
believers. Unsettled questions that contribute to differing interpretations
include:
1) Which events described by scripture are
literal and which are symbolic?
2)
Have
documented historical events already fulfilled the passage?
3)
Will
future events fulfill them “better” or more literally?
4)
Could
there be more than one fulfillment of some passages?
A
passage could also become subject to question three in instances where
scripture uses sarcasm or hyperbole. However, most instances of sarcasm or
hyperbole are obvious. One example of hyperbole would be when Jesus said in
Luke 14:26 that one must “hate his own father and mother and wife and children and brothers and
sisters” to truly put Jesus first and become His
undivided disciple.
An
Illustration
I’d like to close with an illustration to
help explain how apparently contradictory statements can both be true. This
illustration resembles how we can approach scripture.
Imagine you are reading
through handwritten flight logs. You know the pilot who wrote them. You know he
is careful, precise, and honest. However, you find a glaring discrepancy. In
one log, he described a long flight saying, “My
average flight velocity was 500 miles per hour.” Yet, another log described
the same flight saying, “My average
flight velocity was 400 miles per hour.” You initially conclude he made an
error. However, after remembering his careful, scrupulous nature, you decide to
investigate further. You ask, “Is there
any sense or context in which both of these statements could be true at the
same time with no contradiction?”
You look through a few
maps and weather records. You examine his other flight logs for comparison.
Soon the answer becomes clear. The first log recorded his velocity relative to
the ground. The second log recorded his velocity relative to the surrounding
air mass. He spent most of the flight surrounded by a 100-mph jet stream. As it
turns out, both statements were precisely accurate with no contradiction. In
fact, by recording both statements, he ultimately provided more information and
helpful nuance than if he had only recorded one statement for the sake of
simplicity.