Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 17 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
Meditation
is one of the most common practices within the New Age Movement. Meditation is
a spiritual practice that originated with Eastern religions such as Buddhism
and Hinduism. The goal is to achieve an altered state of consciousness to
positively transform one’s consciousness. Meditation techniques include sensory
deprivation, stillness of mind, inward concentration, mantra repetition, and/or
mental visualization.1
Meditation
(sometimes also called mindfulness) has surged in popularity in recent years,
including within schools and major corporations.2,3,4 In 2018, a Pew
Research Center study found that 40% of Americans meditated at least once a
week, including 49% of evangelicals—often as
an attempt to get closer to God.5
Within
Christendom, the terms typically used for meditation/mindfulness-type practices
are contemplative prayer or centering prayer. In December 2020, Christianity
Today endorsed an influential organization called Contemplative Outreach
that taught a combination of mantra meditation and silent meditation, despite
denials.6,7,8
Numerous
studies over the decades have shown that meditation/mindfulness can cause severely
adverse effects. The largest study ever conducted, published in 2017, focused
on experienced, mentally healthy, highly educated meditators. Most of the participants
experienced fear, anxiety, panic, paranoia, and depression. About half
experienced social impairment, occupational impairment, hallucinations,
delusions, and physical pain. A minority experienced rage, sleeplessness,
suicidal thoughts, and hospitalization.9
Likewise,
a 1976 study (Sage Journals) found that meditation can sometimes lead to severe
psychiatric problems.10 A 1981 study (Journal of
Transpersonal Psychology) found that meditation can lead to depersonalization,
derealization, panic attacks, anxiety, tension, agitation, and exacerbate
depression to the point of suicide.11 A 1990 study (National
Institute of Health) found that meditation can lead to depersonalization and
derealization, leading to panic and anxiety.12 A 1992 study (National
Institute of Health) of long-term meditators found that a majority had experienced
adverse effects.13 A 2001 study (Mental Health, Religion
& Culture) examined cases of manic or psychotic illness precipitated by
meditation.14 A 2007 study (National Institute of Health) found
that meditation can cause some practitioners to develop psychosis.15
A 2018 study (Yoga Journal) found that meditation can be detrimental to
survivors of traumatic experiences.16,17
Accounts
of adverse effects have been covered in the media as well, including severe
panic attacks, psychosis, depression, and hospitalization. Even though adverse
effects are common, they are not typically discussed because 1) it is poor
advertising for the multi-billion-dollar industry, 2) people often feel ashamed
and experience self-blame for adverse effects, and 3) the moderate positive
effects are often overhyped.18,19,20
Many of
the adverse effects reported by practitioners are considered by virtually all
spiritual traditions—including
Christianity—to be inducible by dark spiritual
forces. Examples include paranoia, confusion, visions, hallucinations,
involuntary movements, grotesque nightmares, out-of-body experiences, hearing
voices, seeing spiritual entities, and feeling like being controlled or
possessed.21
1.
Gordon Melton, 1990, New Age Encyclopedia, pgs.
284-286 (Gordon Melton is a Distinguished Professor of American Religious
History at Baylor University’s Institute for Studies in Religion)
2.
American Psychological Association, 2018, “Trauma-sensitive
mindfulness: Practices for safe and transformative healing,” by Dr. David
Treleaven
3.
Guardian, 1/23/2016, “Is Mindfulness Making Us Ill?”
4.
Yoga Journal, 4/16/2018, “The Dark Side of
Meditation: How to Avoid Getting Stuck with Pain From the Past”
5.
Pew Research Center, 1/2/2018, “Meditation is common
across many religious groups in the U.S.”
6.
Christianity Today, 12/10/2020, “Centering Prayer in
Our Tumultuous Times”
7.
Contemplative Outreach website, “About Us”
(https://www.contemplativeoutreach.org/about-us/)
8.
Contemplative Outreach website, “Centering Prayer”
(https://www.contemplativeoutreach.org/centering-prayer-method/)
9.
Public Library of Science Journal, 5/24/2017, “The
Varieties of Contemplative Experience: A Mixed-Methods Study of
Meditation-Related Challenges in Western Buddhists,” by Dr. Willoughby
Britton (Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior at Brown University
Medical School)
10.
Sage Journals (Volume 39, Issue 2), October 1976, “Psychiatric
Problems Precipitated by Transcendental Meditation,” by Dr. Arnold Lazarus
(Rutgers University Graduate School of Applied & Professional Psychology)
11.
Journal of Transpersonal Psychology (Vol.13, No.2),
1981, “Psychiatric Complications of Meditation Practice,” by Dr. Mark
Epstein (Harvard Medical School) and Dr. Jonathan Lieff (Boston University
Medical School)
12.
National Institute of Health’s National Library of
Medicine, 1990, “Depersonalization and Meditation,” by Dr. Richard
Castillo (Harvard University Anthropology Department)
13.
National Institute of Health’s National Library of
Medicine, 1992, “Adverse Effects of Meditation: A Preliminary Investigation
of Long-Term Meditators,” Dr. David Shapiro (University of California
Irvine Psychiatry Department)
14.
Mental Health, Religion & Culture (Volume 4, Issue
2), 2001, “Mania Precipitated by Meditation: A Case Report and Literature
Review,” Dr. Graeme Yorston (University of Chester Faculty of Health and
Social Care)
15.
National Institute of Health’s National Library of
Medicine, 2007, “Meditation-Induced Psychosis,” by Dr. H. J. H. Kuijpers
(Vincent van Gogh Institute for Psychiatry; Venray, Netherlands)
16.
American Psychological Association, 2018, “Trauma-sensitive
mindfulness: Practices for safe and transformative healing,” by Dr. David
Treleaven
17.
Yoga Journal, 4/16/2018, “The Dark Side of
Meditation: How to Avoid Getting Stuck with Pain from the Past”
18.
Guardian, 1/23/2016
19.
Catherine Wikholm and Miguel Farias, 2015, The
Buddha Pill: Can Meditation Change You?”
20.
Yoga Journal, 4/16/2018
21.
Steven Bancarz, 12/19/2019, “New Study Finds
Meditation Is Mentally & Emotionally Dangerous”