Content from
this article is duplicated in Chapter 13 of the book, HOW TO BECOME A FALSE
PROPHET.
The
Toronto Blessing was a highly influential supposed Christian revival that began
in 1994 at Toronto Airport Christian Fellowship (TACF). The hallmark
manifestation of the Toronto Blessing was holy laughter, which traces its
modern roots to Rodney Howard-Browne of The River megachurch in Tampa Bay.1,2
Howard-Browne became known in the 1990s as the Holy Ghost bartender. It was
common for attendees at his services to appear drunk with joy, break into
uncontrollable holy laughter, or fall to the ground slain in the spirit.3
Like
Hinn’s, Howard-Browne’s ministry was not a member of the Evangelical Council of
Financial Accountability,4 and would not disclose publicly what
Howard-Browne earns or any other financial aspects of the ministry.5
Howard-Browne’s Bachelor’s, Master’s, and Doctorate of Ministry were all
obtained in a span of three years at an unaccredited Bible School.6
Howard-Browne’s
watershed moment came in the spring of 1993 when he spoke for 18 straight weeks
at the 10,000-seat Carpenter’s Home Church in Lakeland, Florida, and started a
laughter revival movement that spread across the world.7,8,9
Alarmingly, Howard-Browne repeatedly insisted that attendees of the Lakeland
meetings not pray when he was about to lay hands on them.10
That same
year, Howard-Browne imparted his anointing at Kenneth Hagin’s Rhema Bible
Training Center and Oral Roberts University (ORU), leading to the cancellation
of classes. Uproarious laughter broke out even as Howard-Browne preached on
hell.
Howard-Browne
asserted that holy laughter and other manifestations were commonplace during
the Great Awakenings. However, he omitted that both modern church historians
and revivalists of the day disagreed about the nature of the manifestations,
with explanations including the Holy Spirit, mass hysteria, demonic
manifestations, or some combination thereof. The 1801 Cane Ridge Revival in
Kentucky—during which thousands of people
jerked, fell to the ground, danced, barked, and laughed—was also known for rampant drunkenness and sexual immorality.11
Also in
1993, Howard-Browne appeared on Kenneth Copeland’s TV show. Howard-Browne and
Copeland laid on hands and imparted convulsing laughter to attendees while laughing
and speaking in tongues themselves.12 Online analyses of the video
and transcript of the meeting led some to allege Howard-Browne and Copeland
were speaking in demonic tongues.
Saint
Louis Vineyard pastor Randy Clark received an impartation of Howard-Browne’s
anointing at the Rhema Bible Training Center and began imparting it in his own
church. He then passed it to a large majority of attendees at a January 1994
meeting at the Toronto Airport Vineyard, which kicked off the Toronto Blessing.13,14
In the
following months, nightly gatherings were marked by manifestations such as
laughing, falling over, shaking, imitating animals, and drunkenness.15,16
The manifestations spread to many other denominations and nations.17
They eventually became so contentious that the Vineyard severed ties with
Arnott’s church, arguing that they were excessive, exploitive, and unbiblical.18,19
Ontario
Theological Seminary professor Dr. James Beverley published arguably the most
detailed examination of the revival,20 which included interviews of
key figures such as John Wimber, Paul Cain, Mike Bickle, John Arnott, Randy
Clark, and Rodney Howard-Browne. He also discussed criticisms leveled by
leaders such as author/ex-New Ager Warren Smith and radio host Hank Hanegraaff.
21 Beverley included both positive and negative feedback and concluded
the revival was at best a mixed blessing.22
Beverley
did not dispute Hanegraaff’s insinuation that some of the manifestations were
demonic in nature. Nor did he dispute Warren Smith’s rebuke of Toronto leaders
for failing to warn against demonic manifestations. This failure was glaring
since many Vineyard leaders, including Wimber and Arnott, said they had years
of experience indicating such manifestations can be demonic.23
Both
Beverley and Hanegraaff pointed out that the Toronto manifestations were
duplicated in Eastern religions and the New Age movement.24 A
well-known non-Christian UK Telegraph journalist named Mick Brown documented
his visit to Toronto where he experienced the same powerful impartation he
previously received from a Hindu guru.25
Both
Hanegraaff and Beverley considered that some of the manifestations were
attributable to psychological factors such as mass hypnosis, auto-suggestion,
peer pressure, heightened expectations, the star status of the leaders, and
people working themselves into an altered state of consciousness.26
Both
Beverley and Hanegraaff asserted that Howard-Browne and the Toronto leaders
misapplied Acts 2:1-3 to justify an unbiblical manifestation of drunkenness in
the Holy Spirit. They agreed the text indicates people mocked the Christians as
being drunk because they misinterpreted the other languages at Pentecost as the
babble of drunk people, not because the Christians displayed slurred speech or
compromised motor skills. Likewise, they said Ephesians 5:18 contrasts
(not likens) the effects of the Spirit with that of alcohol.27
Beverley
and Hanegraaff agreed that the Toronto meetings regularly violated Paul’s
instructions from 1 Corinthians 14 to conduct meetings in a peaceful and
orderly manner, particularly in the practice of spiritual gifts.28
They also pointed out (along with top Vineyard leaders) a lack of key
components in historical revivals such as reverential awe for God, proclamation
of God’s Word, and conviction of sin.29
Beverley
and Warren agreed that Toronto leaders tragically promoted an unbiblical,
anti-intellectual spirit.30 For example, they suggested Christians
should never attempt to discern or judge the revival. They used pompous,
intimidating language against those who sincerely questioned the revival or
manifestations.31 They issued reckless and divisive prophecies
against those who did not embrace the revival.32
Along
these lines, a public incident occurred in 1995 between Hanegraaff and
Howard-Browne. When Hanegraaff attended a Howard-Browne service, Howard-Browne
publicly warned him he would drop dead if he criticized what God was doing. He
then reiterated the warning to the entire congregation.33
Beverley and Hanegraaff pointed to high-profile, miraculous healing claims
by the Toronto leaders that were subsequently debunked.34,35,36 Both
Beverley and Arnott asserted that God mostly seemed to be performing emotional
healing in Toronto.37,38 In response, Hanegraaff and other critics said that many attendees experienced either
demonic oppression or temporary euphoria that dissipated followed by
disillusionment and confusion.39
Since
thousands of sincere believers regularly gathered in prayer at the Toronto
Blessing, it makes sense for God to have genuinely touched many people through
the revival even if there was a foul impartation at the root of it, courtesy of
Benny Hinn and/or Rodney Howard-Browne.
1.
Christianity Today, 10/24/1994, “Is Laughing for the
Lord Holy? Airport Vineyard’s ‘Blessing’ draws Toronto charismatic crowds.”
2.
Time, 8/15/1994, “Laughing for the Lord: Revivalist
fervor has invaded the Church of England”
3.
Tampa Bay Tribune, 6/27/1999, “The Holy Ghost
Bartender”
4.
Ibid.
5.
Charisma, August 1994, “Praise the Lord and Pass the
New Wine,” by Julia Duin (also see Christian Research Journal, Winter 1995,
page 43, “An Evening with Rodney Howard-Browne,” by Julia Duin)
6.
Tampa Bay Tribune, 6/27/1999
7.
Charisma, August 1994
8.
Tampa Bay Tribune, 6/27/1999
9.
Tampa Bay Times, 4/16/2020, “Preaching conspiracies:
Coronavirus puts Tampa pastor’s beliefs into mainstream spotlight”
10.
Rodney Howard-Browne, 3/9/1993, Carpenter’s Home
Church, Lakeland, Florida, Audiotape Transcript (quoted by Hank Hanegraaff,
9/20/2022, “The Counterfeit Revival: Modern-Day Mesmerists (Part Four)”)
11.
Charisma, August 1994
12.
Andrew Strom, 2010 documentary, “Kundalini Warning:
Are False Spirits Invading the Church”
13.
Christianity Today, 10/24/1994
14.
Washington Post, 1/2/1996, “FILLED WITH HO-HO-HOLY
SPIRIT”
15.
Christianity Today, 3/7/2014, “The Enduring Revival:
The ‘Toronto Blessing’ in 1994 was odd and controversial—but its benefits have
lasted.”
16.
Washington Post, 1/2/1996
17.
Time, 8/15/1994
18.
Christianity Today, 3/7/2014
19.
Washington Post, 1/2/1996
20.
Christianity Today, 3/7/2014
21.
James Beverley, 1995, Holy Laughter and the Toronto
Blessing: An Investigative Report
22.
Christianity Today, 3/7/2014
23.
Beverley, Holy Laughter, pgs. 89-94
24.
Ibid., pg. 90
25.
Telegraph, 12/3/1994, “Unzipper Heaven, Lord. Ha-ha,
Ho-ho, He-he.” by Mick Brown
26.
Beverley, Holy Laughter, pgs. 32, 158
27.
Ibid., pgs. 90-91
28.
Ibid., pgs. 98-100
29.
Ibid., pgs. 91-92
30.
Ibid., pgs. 155-156
31.
Ibid., pg. 94
32.
Ibid., pgs. 146-147
33.
Hank Hanegraaff, 6/10/2009, “The Counterfeit
Revival: Rodney Howard-Browne and the ‘Toronto Blessing’ (Part 1)”
34.
Ibid.
35.
Beverley, Holy Laughter, pgs. 105-107
36.
Washington Post, 1/2/1996
37.
Ibid.
38.
Christianity Today, 3/7/2014
39.
Tampa Bay Tribune, 6/27/1999